Peanut Gallery Vancouver City Council
| | Est. 12,026 HE | |

Beach Safety and Marine Protection

Motion 15 · Park Board Meeting, June 1, 2026

Summary

  • Direction to the board chair to advocate to Transport Canada, the Department of Fisheries and Oceans, and the Vancouver Port Authority for a coordinated marine safety framework covering: standardized exclusion zones for personal watercraft around swim areas and beaches; simplified, consistent whale proximity rules with improved public signage; and coordinated derelict vessel response.
  • Park Board expressed willingness to host safety signage and whale-awareness information at park facilities, boat launches, and beach access points.
  • Brought in response to a series of incidents including swimmer near-misses at Sunset Beach, derelict boats washing ashore, and the May 4, 2026 whale strike involving a personal watercraft.
  • Mover drew on professional experience operating jet skis for surf lifesaving patrols in Sydney, noting that Sydney's 2001 personal watercraft restrictions were effective because they were paired with swim zone infrastructure, coordinated signage, and inter-agency communication, not the ban alone.
  • Commissioner Virdi opposed, noting a recently announced $258 million federal investment in BC coastal protection already addresses several measures in the motion.
  • Chair (Commissioner Digby) opposed, characterizing the motion as too broad and unfocused to produce concrete outcomes, and expressing preference for a staff report on specific park board actions.
  • Commissioner Christensen supported it as a collaborative, non-prescriptive signal of willingness to work with other agencies, particularly on signage using anticipated federal funding.

Vote

Transcript

30 segments

Howard. Thank you. The motion is carried and we'll therefore move on to the final motion entitled Beach Safety and Marine Protection. Motion was moved by Commissioner Bastiavansky. Is there a seconder for that? I see Commissioner Jensen has seconded that. Commissioner Bastiavansky, you have five minutes to introduce your motion. Please go ahead.

Yes, thank you, Chair. So I want to start by thanking you for your earlier motion for acknowledging the whale strike in the harbor. But we've had a series of incidents, actually. We've had a swimmer near misses at Sunset Beach, derelict boats washing up, and now the whale strike. And the whale strike I see as an escalation of the same problem, is that there's overlapping jurisdiction in our harbor, and it's causing the... it's causing these safety issues.

These reflect a crowded waterfront that's outpacing our current safety framework. I'm asking that we align to give the chair a mandate to advocate to other levels of government for safety, infrastructure, clear whale guidance, and coordination on derelict vessels. By acting now, we set up this chair and this board and the next to advocate for a safer, coordinated waterfront. This is exactly what... This is... focused on park board jurisdiction, which is off our beaches and our swim areas. I also want to note a comment earlier was by the chair about Sydney Harbour, and I want to note my personal lived experience there. And I was part of Surf Lifesaving and supported emergency services by operating a jet ski professionally. held a silver medallion in jet ski operations. I used to patrol from Cronulla Port Hacking up to the entrance of Sydney Harbour. And they did in 2001, they made that change. But what they did was they didn't just restrict jet skis. That was one thing. The harbour's very different there. It's very narrow, it's crowded, it's very active. But it wasn't just a ban. The ban wasn't what made the difference. Sydney invested in its infrastructure, swim zones, signage, coordinated awareness when there were whales in the harbour. And that broader approach is what I believe our inlet actually needs. We need practical safety measures that reflect our current reality. The whale strike was simply the catalyst, but that's not the entire issue. Vancouver's waterfront has become more crowded and complex, and this is about modernizing marine safety infrastructure and coordination. And we want, this is about swimmer safety, right? Like I saw just today, a rental jet ski go flying through our swim area at English Bay. Can we put her on mute?

Commissioner Howard, we can still hear you in the room if you'd like to go.

We have 15 minutes.

Commissioner Howard, we can hear you live in the public meeting if you'd like to go on mute. Thank you.

Extend Commissioner Vasivansky by 30 seconds, please. Thank you.

And so we've had these swimmer incidents. And so what I'm asking for is more specific as well. So the current operators in the area that rent out jet skis, they already have several things in mind. So what the better operator is doing is getting the jet skis to stay 300 metres away from swimming beaches and swimming areas. Now, we would need the Vancouver Port Authority to actually map that out, so make that permanent. The Port Authority is also responsible for these swim areas, so that would mean buoys and markers, and also Transport Canada is responsible for the channel, right? So they need to coordinate to keep these vessels away from our beaches. And the Park Board is also willing to help out. We are a willing partner because we have the space where you can put these safety signages, these maps, these whale awareness information. Another specific request is to Department of Fisheries and Transport Canada around the rules around proximity to whales. I think that it's too difficult right now. People have a difficult time understanding how far because it depends on the type of whale, what time of year it is, so it's seasonal, and whether it has a calf. And for most people in Vancouver, they would not be able to identify or tell the different type of whale, so they don't necessarily know. The other side is that we want to be able to, like the park board is advocating for safe outdoor recreation in our beaches. And so anywhere that they swim around like Stanley Park or Spanish Banks, we really do want to push jet ski and motorized personal watercraft like out of those areas. But we would need the port authority to help do that. And for there to be a standard distance from Wales to make it simplified and put signage at all the entry points all over the harbour and the park board would be a civic leader willing to help out because we have a lot of those spaces. where that incident happened with the whale, there was no speed sign. It's not clearly marked out whether they were supposed to be there because they were close to shore. They were obviously speeding, but nowhere in that area does it say what the actual speed limit is.

So these are specific requests, and that's what I would like to talk to the board about tonight. Thank you.

Thank you, Commissioner.

Commissioners, do you have any, is there anything out of order in this motion? No. Seeing none, is there a seconder for this motion? No. I'll see Commissioner Hare is willing to second this motion. It was already seconded. by Commissioner Jensen. Okay, that skipped my memory. So we'll move on to comments, to questions to the mover. Does anyone have a question to the mover they'd like to ask? Okay, Commissioner Hare has a question.

Thank you for bringing this forward. Just a very small question. So do you love whales?

I absolutely love whales. And I'll share what an experience I had on a jet ski. I was surrounded by, it was a pod of dolphins, but they surfaced around me. There was a pod of about 100 of them. But I turned the motor off. So that's the whole thing. When you get too close to these animals in order to protect them, you need to shut your motor off. You shouldn't be traveling at high speed in those areas. If you can't see ahead, you shouldn't be going that fast. If you don't know that, you shouldn't be on the craft. And so this motion is really about, it is protecting whales and dolphins and other cetaceans. Because jet skis, I think there is a place for them in Burrard Inlet. Burrard Inlet is not Sydney Harbour. It's much bigger, and it's not as crowded. Sydney Harbour is very, it's packed, so it makes a lot more sense. And they moved it down to Bodney Bay, which is a very large body of water, so people can't actually do that, and there's fewer whales in there. But yes, I love them.

Perfect. Thank you.

Whatever, man. It's late. Let me sleep.

Further questions to the mover? I have a question. This is a very long and complicated motion. approximately an essay in length. Do you feel this motion would be better handled as a staff report on what the park board could actually do, or do you prefer it's scattered and disconnected elements as they weave an elaborate pastiche of intention and question marks?

Thank you for the question, Commissioner, I think. Look, this is requesting, this is giving the authority to the chair, right? Like, we need to go talk to our neighbors.

To do what? To do everything?

Well, there are specific departments that are responsible for specific aspects of this. That's why it's a problem.

If I said that this motion was a chaotic mess, would you agree with me?

So a complex problem requires a complex solution. That's why we're asking for higher levels of government to coordinate amongst themselves. We're a willing participant. We're here on the ground floor. People witnessed it from our jurisdiction. And we're asking for the Department of Fisheries to help out, the Transport Canada to help out.

So are you aware that the federal government just announced $258 million to protect the BC coast and the Port of Vancouver, and that includes signs and underwater monitoring systems? So telling the port how to do their job when they're already going to do their job... I don't think that's wise. I don't know. I don't think I could support this because I think the federal government is stepping up and the port is already stepping up and implementing measures that you're already mentioning here.

Was there a question in there?

Yeah, so the federal government is investing in its coastline. But the thing is, the local municipal governments and those that are there on the front line are the ones that are asking for the specific infrastructure. So there's very little that Ottawa is going to know more about the Vancouver Harbour than the people that live here. And again, the ownership of specific parts of the problem, the ownership is clear. And so we're asking on each area of government to do their responsibility. Like police, marine, like they're the ones that do enforcement. You've got the Department of Fisheries that's responsible for the distance away from whales and the signage that goes with that. The Port Authority is responsible for actually funding and putting those signs up in all the locations where you could launch a boat. Park Board has a lot of those places where you can launch a personal watercraft from a beach or a boat ramp or a or somewhere else in the harbor, like a dock. And so these things are already clear. We need to ask for them. And the funding is being made available by the federal government. And we need to have a specific ask. And I think that the park board in its jurisdiction can advocate for safe recreation and point out that there's infrastructure needed. And here are specific examples. And by the way...

Thank you, Commissioner. I think you've answered the Commissioner's question quite successfully, and we understand your position on it. So are there any further questions to the mover? Do I see any more questions to the mover? Seeing no questions to the mover, we'll now move on towards a vote. And we'll ask commissioners for comments on the motion here. And Commissioner Verdi, it looks like you'd like to go first.

So I think this is overstepping our jurisdiction, telling the Port Authority what to do when they are spending a lot of money and working with the federal government to put up signs to install monitoring systems and to do exactly what you're asking them to do here in this motion. I think we're overstepping our jurisdiction, and I think it's not going to be pretty when we get an answer saying we're already doing this.

Thank you, Commissioner Verity. Commissioner Christensen.

Yeah, I think we can all recognize that banning watercraft is not our jurisdiction. But I do think this motion hits a nice balance here where it's advocating. And I think, for me, the really critical part is item C, which is that we're expressing our willingness to support that signage, so that federal government funding. If they want to put signs up, we are saying, yes, put signs up at our beaches. I think this motion signals that we're willing to work with the other parties on this, that we recognize the issues, and that we're working towards solving it with them. So I think this is a very collaborative motion. I don't think it takes a harsh banning approach, but I think it really focuses on what we can do as the park ward and how we can work with other agencies in this. And I do want to thank Commissioner Basfanski for bringing his sort of lived experiences around, you know, waterways to this motion. So I'll be supporting it.

Commissioner Hare, and could we see Part B up there on the screen, by the way, Madam Clerk, just so we can see the whole motion?

And Commissioner Hare, please go ahead. Comments before we vote?

I just want to thank the Commissioner for bringing this forward. I think it is our responsibility to bring attention to certain problems and that, again, we do want to protect the whales, but we do also want to protect people that use motorized sports. and are in the water as well. So I think this is a great balance. And moving forward, we're also building relationships with different levels of government. And I don't think you're being commanding or telling them what to do, but you're perhaps leading or saying that we are willing to work with them and our beaches and our parks are open for signages and better communication with those that use our facilities moving forward. And yeah, thank you so much for bringing this forward.

Commissioner Jensen.

I'll just keep this brief. Again, I will be supporting this. I do appreciate the fact that this takes what hopefully is an isolated incident of an incident involving a skidoo and a whale and looks at it across our system and looks to make our parks, our beaches and our adjacent waterways safer for all types of users. And that's ultimately what I think we want to do, is whether this is a whale or whether this is a child or whether this is a paddleboarder, that everyone deserves that opportunity to use these water spaces safely and with respect. So thank you, and I'll look to support this.

I'll conclude with my own comments that... I think this is a chaotic mix of intentions and doesn't make clear at all a specific direction, provides an unlimited number of opportunities for comment and discussion, which basically means that none of it will happen. So as it's such an unfocused motion, I am definitely going to vote against it and will now move to a vote. So for commissioners, I ask you for a show of hands. All those in favour of the motion as submitted there, please raise your hand. I see Commissioner Hare, Commissioner Jensen, Commissioner Christensen, Commissioner Boustivansky. All those opposed to the motion, please raise your hand. I see Commissioner Howard, Commissioner Verdi and Commissioner Digby. So the motion indeed passes and we'll leave it at that. Moving on, we'll ask for notice of motions. Do commissioners have a notice of motions for the next meeting, which is not until July the 13th? Do I see on July 20th is a special meeting? July, any notice of motions? Seeing none, then we'll move on to other business. Do any members have other business?

I see no other business from anybody else. Do any members have inquiries they want to leave with the staff?

Seeing no inquiries, then we'll adjourn this meeting. There's no further business.