← Public Hearing February 24, 2026
Reminded to enable video to confirm quorum. The meeting is being live streamed on the city's website and YouTube and meeting progress will be updated regularly on ex-Advanced City Clerk. In case of an emergency where we have to evacuate the chamber, please direct your attention to the glass doors. You just walk past them, past the pillar and hang a left. And please walk down the stairs. If that exit is obstructed for any reason whatsoever, please note that there are four exits at the side of these chambers. And if you need mobility assistance, please stay in place and one of our super friendly team members will come and help you out of this place. There's also a defibrillator at the end of the chamber here. I do want to acknowledge that we are hosting today's public hearing on the traditional territories of the Musqueam, Squamish, and TTsleil-Waututh First Nations, and I do want to thank them for their generosity, hospitality, and loving care. They show this great land that we get to live, work, and play on. I also want to acknowledge the immense contributions of our incredible team members throughout the City of Vancouver who work hard every single day to make this place a better place. So with that, can we please get a roll call?
Yes, Mayor Sim is in the chair. Councillor Kirby Young has a leave of absence, civic business from 5 p.m. onwards. Councillor Domenato is not in the chamber. Councillor Bligh has a leave of absence, civic business from 6 p.m. onwards. Councillor Frye.
Councillor Montague. Present. Councillor Klassen has a leave of absence in civic business from 5 p.m. onwards. Councillor Meyers?
I'm present, thanks.
Councillor Gilles?
Present.
Councillor Orr? Councillor Maloney is not in the chamber. We do have quorum, Mayor.
Great, thank you very much. Okay, so before we begin a few announcements, the public may speak in person or by phone or may submit written comments to the Mayor and Council. Speakers may only speak once and will have up to five minutes to comment on the merits of the application. Please state whether you support or oppose the application and if you are a resident of Vancouver. Those representing four or more individuals or groups, including themselves, may speak for up to eight minutes. Each person being represented must confirm their name and presence in person or by phone and may not speak separately. Please follow the live stream or at VanCityClerk on X to track meeting progress and know when your turn to speak is approaching. Please note the live stream has a slight delay. Written comments can be submitted through the Mayor and Council Public Hearing Feedback Form linked on X. If you pre-registered with presentation, stay next to have the clerk advance your slides. A reminder, at public hearings, council acts as a quasi-judicial body and must focus solely on the merits of the rezoning or heritage application. Members may ask clarifying questions of team members or speakers, including the applicant, but should reserve debate until after the speaker's list has closed. After hearing from speakers, council may, one, approve the application principle, Two, approve the application in principle with amendments. Three, refuse the application. Or four, refer the application to team members for further consideration. Please note that a new public speaker podium has been installed on the left side of the public gallery to my right. At the moment, podium heights cannot be adjusted by the clerk. Team members and public speakers, please adjust the podiums as needed using the controls on your right-hand side. Okay, so the first item on the docket is CD-1 rezoning 2268 through 2294 West 3rd Avenue and 1902 through 1912 Mine Street. So before we begin this agenda item, if anyone believes that they have a conflict of interest, now is the time to declare it. Seeing no one's hands up, we're now going to go to the clerk who will read the application and the summary of correspondence received.
This is an application by Marcon Developments Limited to rezone 2268-2294 West 3rd Avenue and 1902-1912 Vine Street from R3-3 Residential District to CD-1 Comprehensive Development District. to permit the development of a 22-story mixed-use building containing 207 rental units with 20% of the residential floor area for below-market rental units and commercial space on the ground floor. A floor space ratio FSR of 7.1 and a height of 71.0 meters, 233 feet, are proposed. The following correspondence has been received since referral to public hearing. 27 pieces of correspondence in support, 43 pieces of correspondence in opposition, and zero pieces of correspondence regarding other aspects related to the application. This represents all correspondence received up to 5 p.m. today.
Great. Thank you very much. Now, this is the first call for speakers. Any speakers for this item who wish to speak to counsel, please call toll-free at 1-833. 353-8610, followed by participant code 1061445-POUND. Before the close of the speakers list, the phone number will be posted on X and displayed during the recess. There will be an opportunity for new speakers and missed speakers to be heard at the end of the registered speakers list. We do have team members from Planning, Urban Design and Sustainability here to present the application.
GOOD EVENING, MAYOR COUNCIL. MY NAME IS OSCAR ERIKSON AND I'M THE RESONING PLANNER FOR THIS APPLICATION LOCATED AT 2268 TO 2294 WEST THIRD AVENUE AND 1902 TO 1912 WINE STREET.
The site, shown in red, is located on the southeast corner of the intersection of 3rd Avenue and Vine Street. The surrounding context consists primarily of apartment buildings with commercial or mixed-use buildings along West 4th Avenue. The site to the west, outlined in yellow, previously housed a Safeway grocery store and is now undergoing redevelopment. The subject site is currently developed with two rental buildings. There are tenants on site eligible for protection under the tenant relocation and protection policy.
Consideration of this application is enabled by the Broadway plan. The site is located in Kitsilano North, Area B, at the western boundary of the plan area. At this location, the plan allows for consideration of rezonings for 100% rental housing with 20% of the residential floor area as below-market rental units. Buildings up to 20 stories and 6.5 FSR can be considered at this location. Minor increases in height and density can be considered for delivery of ground-level local serving retail service uses. Additionally, building heights up to 26 stories can be considered where additional building height helps achieve better urban design outcomes.
The application submitted in August 2024 and revised in July 2025 proposes a mixed-use building of 22 stories at a density of 7.1 FSR. The proposal includes 207 rental units where 20% of the residential floor area is delivered as below-market rental units. In addition to the 6.8 above-grade FSR specified for the sub-area in the Broadway plan, the project includes an additional 0.3 FSR of proposed below-grade commercial use. As the added commercial floor area does not contribute to the perceived bulk or massing of the building, and given the site's proximity to the commercial area on 4th Avenue and the City's objective to encourage employment space, staff support the added below-grade density. Additionally, to provide open green space at grade, including a pedestrian mid-block connector, and to improve retention efforts of neighbors' trees, the applicant has shifted floor area from the east side of the podium and relocated it to the top of the tower, making up the 22nd story. Staff support this adjustment as it improves urban design outcomes.
A virtual Q&A period was held in January 2025, and in total, 276 pieces of correspondence were received. Support was expressed for the contribution to the housing stock, including the delivery of below-market rental units, the added density given its proximity to transit, major arterials, and destinations such as Kitsilano Beach and downtown Vancouver. The attractive building design with ground floor retail enhancing the livability. Concern was expressed for the building height and scale of development, shadowing impact to views and access to daylight, strain on infrastructure and amenities, and displacement of longstanding tenants and loss of existing affordable housing.
In response, staff notes that the building height and the scale of the proposal is consistent with the plan. The incremental changes to the neighborhood character also aligns with expectations of the plan. Future development must adhere to the form of development guidelines outlined in the Broadway plan, ensuring a contextual fit with the neighborhood's character. Further review of the form of development will occur at the development permit stage. Regarding shadowing, the project aligns with the solar access guidelines outlined in the plan. The proposal complies with tower separation guidelines and other guidelines intended to ensure access to daylight and livability. The project does not impact any protected public views. City-funded amenities will be expanded in accordance with the public benefit strategy of the Broadway Plan, and the City will continue to work with Coastal Health, BSB, and TransLink to facilitate the delivery of health care, education, and transit services. The tenant relocation and protection policy was adopted to minimize the impact of tenant displacement. Legible tenants are protected under both the policy itself and the enhanced protections of the Broadway Plan, including the right of first refusal to return to the new building. With all 18 eligible tenants choosing to return, the development will result in a net increase of 187 new purpose-built rental homes to the city's housing stock. Expected DCLs and public art contribution is estimated to $2.3 million. Additionally, the project will deliver 164 market rental units and approximately 43 below-market rental units.
In conclusion, this proposal aligns with the Broadway plan and advances the city's rental housing targets by delivering 207 rental units, of which 20% are below-market rental units. Staff recommend approval, subject to conditions outlined in Appendix B of the report. Staff and the applicant team are available to answer questions. Thank you.
Would the applicant like to present the application?
Good evening, Mayor and Council.
My name is Nick Palala with Marcon. I will not be making a presentation this evening, but I'm happy to answer any questions that you have.
Great. Thank you. Are there any questions from Council to team members or the applicant noting that this is the only opportunity to ask questions of the applicant? Councillor Meiszner.
Yeah, thanks. This is for the applicant. I'm just curious as to what you're envisioning for the retail space, given there's lots of retail nearby.
Yes. One of the reasons that we were looking to create additional commercial space at this location was that the ground plane is served by lots of different retail amenities on 4th Avenue that we think that there's an opportunity for wrapping that corner with retail and commercial that will add vitality like food and beverage and lifestyle programming. And also particularly the below grade, we're finding that with 4th Avenue being such a popular corridor for commercial, that there's a number of uses that don't have the opportunity. They're kind of competed out of the market for the above-grade space, and we think there's wellness programs and other types of facilities that could actually use below-grade space to continue to operate and have business in the area, which is why we... have also proposed to integrate that into this project.
Okay, so something like a gym or something that doesn't necessarily... Wellness, yes. Yoga studios.
Yoga studios, wellness, you know, the cold plunge sauna type stuff. Okay. All these wellness amenities that this community does have, but they've been increasingly squeezed with just competitive retail dynamics along 4th Avenue.
Yeah, okay, great. Thank you.
Thank you very much. Okay, this is the second call for speakers. If there are any speakers for this item who wish to speak to council, please call toll-free at 1-833-353-8610, followed by participant code 1061445 before the close of the speakers list. The phone number will be posted on X and displayed during the recess. We're now going to hear from the public. Any registered speakers in the council chamber, please come forward to the left podium when your name is called. Phone-in speakers will be unmuted when your name is called. Speakers will have up to five minutes to make their comments and should limit their comments to the merits of the application being considered. So our first registered speaker is speaker number one, Jane McFadden. Jane, on the line?
Yes. Hi. Good evening, Mayor, Senate and Council. Thanks for giving me time to speak tonight.
Can you hear me? Okay. My name is Susan Davies. I'm a resident of Kitsilano. I'm also a medical professional who's worked in Kitsilano for the last 36 years. I'm speaking in opposition to the proposal on West 3rd and Vine Street. My primary concern is not so much change itself, it's the lack of comprehensive and transparent mitigation plan for the impact of this project because there are so many other proposals for high towers in this small geographic area. And so I believe this development can't be considered just in isolation. There's dozens of additional high-rise towers planned. We're underway within a few blocks in the same area. And when you layer the projects together, we're looking at a really dramatic increase of the population density, potentially thousands of new residents, without a clear public plan outlining how the infrastructure will keep pace. Infrastructure, I mean roads, parking, the sewers, schools, parks, daycares, preschools, health services, and, of course, emergency access. And as someone myself who works presently in health care, I can tell you that services in this area are already very stretched. Because I have limited time tonight, I'm just going to focus on one specific example, and that's the parking and traffic congestion. I read the report, and the project proposes, as you said earlier, the 207 units. The parking is 88 parking spaces. So for this area, that would be about 200 to 400 residents in that one single building. Where are all the other people going to park? The report does state parking plans will be finalized at the development permit stage. But to me, that leaves a lot of uncertainty. And the reality is that many residents will likely still own vehicles. People have to commute to work. Families drive kids to school and activities. And regardless of people are taking transit, they will be getting their daily deliveries by truck or by car. Trades and service providers will still require access as well as visitors and the ride sharing, and this is all added further pressure. So if parking is insufficient on site, I think that what's going to happen is these vehicles will spill into the surrounding street areas that are already very congested. Emergency vehicle access, the pedestrian safety, and the quality of life I feel will be negatively impacted. Already, I live just across the street, so I'm hearing ambulances blaring every half hour down 4th Avenue, and I'm wondering how will people get emergency care in a timely fashion with further increased congestion? And this is only just the one building. Safeway redevelopment is already underway across the street at the very same intersection. So what we need to consider really is the cumulative effect, which could mean close to 1,000 new residents just in that one little corner. So what I would like to see is the detailed publicly accessible plan that shows how the traffic flow is going to be managed. How will the sewers and utilities be upgraded? Or is 4th Avenue going to be permanently... ripped apart for that or how will schools and health services be expanded i don't see details in that and i think growth needs to be responsible coordinated so i feel this proposal is quite premature and incomplete because the broader consequences of what i've just mentioned haven't been addressed And I read a lot of the Broadway plan. I see the acronym to be determined TBD many times. And I feel if you don't, you don't really have a plan if you have TBD repeated often. So in conclusion, this was just an example of congestion parking issues. Just one of the many areas where there's no, in my opinion, the detailed plan to address the impact of its development. So I'm urging council to pause and require a more comprehensive infrastructure and mitigation strategy and make it clearly available as well as easily accessible to the public before proving the further density at this scale in Kitsilano. Thank you so much for your time.
Great. Thank you. Bye-bye. Thank you, Susan. Okay. Speaker number three, Davrin Lee-Sun.
Can you hear me?
Hello. Good evening, Mayor and City Councillors. My name, as you mentioned, is Darren Leeson, and I've been the owner of the Shoppers Drug Market at the corner of West 4th and Vine Street. We're one block away from this proposed redevelopment. Now, I've been a pharmacist for 46 years, 36 of these in Canada, and I've been at this Shoppers location for 20 years. which is a fair amount of time. And over the past two decades, I've seen 4th Avenue change and grow into one of Vancouver's most popular and desired shopping districts for both residents and retailers. And it's a very trendy place to live, as you know. I've also not seen any new development in the last 20 years.
You know, this proposal is located within the Broadway plan area. and is fully policy compliant, providing over 200 new rental homes, including those below market, which is, you know, I think that's really important in a very popular neighborhood. It may seem that Forth is already a busy shopping area, but as a longtime local business owner, I can tell you that all retailers along the street will gladly welcome an increased customer base, especially in this uncertain economy. In the 20 years I've been here, I've seen many businesses on 4th open and close because it's such a competitive environment and with increased population, it will definitely help survival. I've also seen many seniors being forced to relocate with increased rents. So with the rent controls and increased inventory, the rents might stabilize and make it more affordable for people. This project is my support. It brings new rental stock to the area along with public benefits such as a family playground, retail shops, and a mid-block green pathway connection to the Whole Foods Plaza. Please consider improving this policy-compliant rental proposal in Kitsilano. Thank you for your time.
Mayor and Council, thank you for your time tonight. My name is Alex Downey. I live at 1910 Vine Street in Kitsilano. We are directly impacted by this development. I'm here with my wife, Barbara Downey, to voice our opposition to this rezoning. We are also here to ask you to consider enhancements to the tenant protection relocation plan to consider the impact on those of us that are displaced from townhomes. Most of our neighbors are opposed to this building. Having a tower on this site, the referral report confirms this with, I believe, 69% of respondents against it. But you know that already. Who are we? We are long-term Vancouver residents. We raised our family in our Kitsilano townhome for the past 25 years. Our family lives in this townhome now. As recent retirees, we now live on a fixed income, so we have to consider that. And a little bit about our townhouse complex. It's a 20-unit townhome complex that was completely renovated in 1990, comprised of 15 two-bedroom and five three-bedroom units. We're in one of the three-bedroom units. These are all large 1,200 to 1,400 square feet units with unfinished basements. They're row houses with front and rear porches, level entry to the street. Our townhouses are livable, functional, and affordable family-oriented units. What do we stand to lose if this goes through, if you voted through? We'll lose the unfinished basement space we use for storage, laundry area, and recreation space. We'll lose privacy and quiet because we only have neighbors on two sides now, not above and below. The loss of possible home office space, loss of potential sublet income because it's allowed in our current lease. The ability to age in place by using a bedroom to house a live-in caregiver in the future. And, of course, the loss of the community we have helped to build over the past quarter century. In looking at the different tenant protection policies for municipalities nearby, Vancouver and Burnaby comes to mind. Both, of course, allow a rate of return to a unit in the new building. However, there's some important differences. One of them is that... A national housing standard is applied to reduce the number of bedrooms in the returning unit for certain people. The moving allowances are greater in Burnaby by $400. And in Vancouver, we're paid a moving allowance once of $1,000 for a three-bedroom unit, but not to return to the new building, ironically. So that's a hidden expense in addition to the increased damage deposit that was required to be paid to the new landlord. In Burnaby, developers must post a bond to ensure that the project is completed so the rent top-ups can continue for up to 36 months. Vancouver has not made this a requirement.
The bottom line is that Burnaby does not apply the national housing standard. You get like for like for number of bedrooms. And just yesterday, Surrey announced a major project in Surrey Central. by Ani, which is one of the major developers, to replace 321 units. And part of the stipulation is that they will replace them with like-for-like bedrooms for displaced tenants. So what do we stand to go from a three-bedroom, 1,400-square-foot townhouse possibly to a 388-square-foot one-bedroom apartment in the new tower? That just doesn't seem fair. So as townhome tenants, what we'd like to see happen is that tenants displaced from rental townhomes be allowed to return to a unit in the new building with the same number of bedrooms as before, that the moving allowance be increased to $1,400 to match what Burnaby pays, and also to cover inflation since Vancouver hasn't raised moving allowance since 2015 when the policy came into effect, and also that a second moving allowance be paid so that tenants that do elect to return to the building have some assistance to move back into the new building. There are some precedents for this. The TRPP was changed to relax the national housing standard for single persons returning to new buildings. They can return to a one-bedroom instead of a studio as before. And in 2021, the city allowed tenants of townhomes in the Ashley Marr Co-op in South Vancouver to return to new units with the same number of bedrooms they had before, with two moving allowances paid. So why should the city agree to our request? Citizens of Vancouver, especially long-term tenured tenants, deserve to be treated fairly. The cost to demolish our townhome complex is lower than for a typical three-story walk-up building with an underground parking lot. Some of these savings could go to helping tenants' compensation. Compensation should consider the type of dwelling renters are being displaced from. Applying a one-size-fits-all is neither fair nor equitable.
To conclude, we don't think it's fair that our standard of living should be reduced markedly to improve developers' profitability. I would like to ask council to instruct planning staff to include policies similar to Burnaby and Surrey to require the developer to provide the same number of bedrooms in the replacement units. Thanks for your time. Thank you very much for coming in, Alex.
I have a question for the speaker. I have a question for you. I'm just, I'm trying to find, did you send, you sent over a, PowerPoint presentation.
Yes, I did, but I sent it two hours late.
No, yeah, it's fine. I'm just making sure. It's Alex Downey, right? Yes, I sent it to all, to Mayor and all the Councillors. No, I'm just, yeah, just make sure. You had some very good points. Just make sure I have that. Thank you.
Nope. Speaker number six, Adam Bogoch.
And I hope I pronounced your name correctly.
You did. Thank you, Mayor. Thank you to the Mayor and to the Council for giving us this opportunity. My name is Adam Bogoch. I've lived in Kitsilano for 12 years. I am an owner and resident of the Capers Building, which sits directly behind the proposed site, which I vehemently oppose. A few weeks ago, When the barge struck the Arthur Lang Bridge, traffic across Richmond and Vancouver collapsed into total gridlock. One disruption exposed how inadequate our road systems are. And I begin here because what I'm about to show you is a smaller version of the same problem, but permanent. This rezoning sits directly beside one of the busiest commercial service alleys in Kitsilano, the alley serving Whole Foods, and the Capers Building Complex, which is the entire block on the north side of 4th Avenue between Vine Street and U Street. The alley is not a quiet residential lane. It is a high-intensity loading corridor operating above capacity every day. Delivery trucks line up three to five deep. They park to abreast, they block one another, and they block residents and cyclists. Verbal and physical altercations have broken out. Even the city sent soil testers for the proposed property just a few weeks ago, recently had to back out of the alley because it was impassable. I see this daily from my office above the Whole Foods dock. Next slide, please. Next slide. If you reference the developer's application, pages 17, 35, 36, 38, 41, 44, 45, and 47, yes, there's a lot of them, you will see a pleasant animated mid-block corridor connecting 3rd Avenue through the alley into what they label a public plaza leading to 4th Avenue. You can go to the next slide, please. And the next slide again. This plaza is not public. It is common property, owned, maintained, secured and paid for by the commercial strata of the Capers building. In summer months, signage states that the Whole Foods is for customers only. The developer does not own it. They do not maintain it or insure it. Yet, they are marketing it as a pedestrian through route to support their project. Worse, their rendering of the lane depicts leisurely dog walking and cycling as though this was a residential street. It is not. It is a commercial loading dock. Next slide, please. And the proposed four-level underground park gate entrance would sit directly across from the Whole Foods loading bay, intensifying conflict in the tightest, most constrained part of that corridor. Next slide, please. That's their walkway. Next slide. No other high-rise development in this area sits atop this level of sustained commercial activity. Next slide, please. So to that add... 200 units, add construction vehicles and service vehicles and ride shares and deliveries and bikes and pedestrians and traffic from the Safeway redevelopment across the street there and the congestion from 4th Avenue where buses already straddle lanes because the roads are so narrow. And the sidewalks are even worse for pedestrians. Next slide, please. With this, you are not solving a housing problem. You are creating a predictable safety and infrastructure failure. Drivers will suffer. Cyclists and pedestrians will suffer. Commercial tenants and existing residents will suffer. And yes, the future residents of this tower will suffer. Next slide, please.
Next slide. If sewage and water capacity must be upgraded for densification, then above-ground infrastructure must reflect the same logic. The roads, lanes, sidewalks, and servicing corridors must be capable of handling the population that you are introducing. This alley cannot. Kitsilano can evolve, but evolution must respect context. This proposal, as it stands, totally ignores it. I urge you, do not approve a rezoning application that relies on misrepresented public space, idealized drawings, and infrastructure that already fails under existing demand. This is categorically the wrong project for this location. And I know I'm fighting an uphill battle here, but should this application pass, it needs to be done so with considerable and notable amendments, which should be brought forward for meaningful public debate. Thank you so much. for your time and consideration.
Great. Thank you very much, Adam. Speaker number seven, Ed Evans.
Hi there. Yeah, I'm on the line. Can you hear me?
We can hear you great. Please go ahead.
Okay, yeah. Hi, my name is Ed Evans. I'm a Vancouver resident, and I'm calling to offer my support for this application. So I used to live in Kislano and Fairview for many years before relocating to East Van because I couldn't find suitable housing in the neighborhood. And so like many others, I couldn't stay in the neighborhood. I still know the area very well and spend lots of time there. It's an incredibly connected neighborhood with access to beaches, parks, schools, shops, transit and community management. Now that I have a family of my own, I appreciate even more how ideal this area is for kids. It's walkable, safe and families can meet their daily needs without having to rely on a car. I also strongly support the inclusion of pedestrian friendly design features in new developments. The proposed mid-block connection linking West 3rd Ave and West 4th Ave is a great example. Overall, I believe this is a great proposal that responds to the needs of the community and the city. Thank you very much.
Thank you very much. Speaker number eight, Louis Villegas.
Is it on? Yeah, okay. Good evening. So my name is Ruth Cherry. I've lived in Vancouver since 1985, and I'm opposed to the CD1 rezoning, 2268, 2294, Worcester Avenue, and 1902 to 1912 Vine Street. And what concerns me is that we are told that there is a housing shortage. There certainly is. There's a shortage of affordable housing. I don't think that the number of towers that are in this proposal, this proposal, but also the buildings in the surrounding area are truly going to address that because the rent is not affordable. I don't know whom it is. And maybe if you have three people sharing a small place, I don't know. But as it stands, it's not. And the floor space is quite cramped as well. People have talked about the narrow streets. I often go to Kitsilano. I lived there for several years. And it's very congested. So if you have this building and a number of other buildings in the same area, it will be more so. And I think there will be, as the gentleman, one or two speakers back said, there will be more road rage. People are... not very patient. It concerns me that there's such a it seems a rush to have a number of these buildings built or at least approved to be built without consideration of infrastructure. such as schools, parks, health facilities, and it has to be more livable. It feels like we're losing our status as a livable city because we're allowing development to come at a rate that isn't sustainable.
Kitsilano has quite a unique character. I remember coming to it in the 70s when I was quite small, and it's changed substantially since then. But it still has character that is hard to find in other parts of the city. With... This building and a number of other buildings, the fabric of that neighborhood is being changed, and I don't think it's for the better.
So developers and construction companies say that they're, in essence, doing us a favor by building these tall buildings that are overcrowded, are overcrowding the area. I don't think they're truly concerned about... Us, people who live here, they're concerned about making money. That's their mandate. As for the 20% that are under market value, we don't know how many people are going to be returning. Therefore, how many people in the public, outside of those who are being displaced, are truly going to have access to that 20%. So I hope you refuse this, and thank you for listening.
Thank you, Ruth. Speaker number 10, Alejandra Aguirre.
Sorry, I know I mispronounced your name.
Good evening, Mayor and Council. Firstly, I'd like to acknowledge that Council's job is not an easy one. You have to weigh complex and often competing priorities. I'd also like to highlight the power that you hold. Power to have direct and significant effect on people's lives. And as we all know, with great power comes great responsibility. As a 10-year resident of the townhouse complex affected by this application, I, my family, and my neighbors will be greatly affected by your decision. For us, this is not just another rezoning application. Unless you're directly affected in this way, it's truly hard to understand what this is like. Growth is inevitable. The form it takes is a choice. There's substantial research showing that the form buildings have affects quality of life. That ground-oriented housing, townhouses, low-rise buildings, homes with direct street access, foster stronger neighborhood interaction and a greater sense of belonging. Human-scale development supports vibrant, safe communities because it encourages everyday social contact. Tall residential towers reduce informal interaction and increase anonymity. Our townhouse complex is not just a collection of units. It's a community. Neighbors know each other. Children play. People look out for each other. Replacing our community with a tall tower is a dramatic shift. It not only changes the skyline and shadowing, but also the rhythm and character of our neighborhood. We all know that the rental market has shifted towards more availability and softer rents. Current developments and kits will eventually add over 10,000 rental units to our neighborhood. some low rises, 11 towers at the south end of Burrard Bridge, and five other towers you have approved so far. We already had a misstep in the 60s and 70s when the city rezoned to allow 10- to 12-storey towers. A half dozen were built until community action successfully stopped them from spreading further, preserving the character of our neighbourhood. This will undoubtedly happen again. I'm not saying don't build. I'm saying build within the neighborhood's style and character. Besides the aforementioned half-dozen 12-storey towers, most building in kits are three storeys. So build more of these or slightly higher on sites that are less dense. Build livable units that meet the BC housing guidelines, not overpriced shoeboxes. Provide fair replacement for displaced residents. Suites of similar size. Developers may be required to offer suites at a similar rent, but they are half the size. My family would go from 1,200 square feet to 600 square feet. So really, residents' rents are doubling per square foot. I speak to you in the spirit of the city's mission statement, which reads, create a great city of communities that cares about our people, our environment, and our opportunities to live, work, and prosper. Kitsilano is like a golden egg, fragile, precious, and irreplaceable. Careful hands are needed to nurture it, because once it's broken, its value and beauty can simply not be restored. Its value is not monetary. I respectfully ask you to consider whether this proposal strengthens the fabric of our neighborhood or fundamentally alters it in ways that cannot be undone. I ask you to look into your hearts and souls and ask yourselves, in 20 years, will you be proud of what you've done to Kitsilano? Were you responsible with the power you held? I know this is not an easy decision for you. You have pressures coming at you from all sides. But I ask you to respect our neighborhood and those who live there and choose community over profit.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you very much. Speaker number 11, Jennifer O'Keefe.
Hello? Can you hear me?
We can hear you great. Please go ahead.
Okay, thank you. I'm here today to urge you to vote no and delay this approval until the developer and city can demonstrate stronger tenant protections are put in place than current. As heard previously at the last council meeting that approved rezoning for the Broadway plan, tenants from the BGH and Canby area spoke out and told city councillors their personal stories about not being rehoused and offered compensation. Instead, they were forced to move out of the city completely. Tenants want assurances that they will be rehoused and allowed to return into equivalent size family units for their family's needs and for the amount of people that are actually living in the units. I know firsthand how weak protections are in my parents' building, which is this building. Residents of the building are currently paying below market rates. Residents are terrified to come and speak. There's been a few of them at City Hall, but most of them are too scared to come and speak at City Hall because they're concerned that there will be repercussions if they do. Families asked the developer at one of the Zoom consultation meetings that was held that they would be rehoused in units of the same number of bedrooms, and they were told that they would be reassessed later on to determine units size. and that there was a limit of how many units would be available below market rate. For many, this means pressure on families to split up or even for their children to move out early, with many not being able to afford further education without being able to live at home with their parents. In the current building, many of the units are multi-generational family units with grandparents, parents, and young children living in the suites together. Many families rely on the shared housing for child care, elder care, and affordability, and now they're fearing that they will be crammed into studio apartments or one-bedrooms. Is this displacement disguised as development? This Broadway redevelopment plan represents a massive transfer of land from residents in the neighbourhoods to private corporations and investment firms. If we allow this to proceed, corporations will continue to control the majority of the rental housing, dissipating market rates and occupancy as they see fit. Rental housing will become like diamonds, scarce and withheld and rationed, while families struggle to afford a place to live. I ask you to delay this proposal until the developer and city staff can demonstrate that residents will be protected adequately, that families will be assisted with stronger policies to protect them than what is currently in place, and that the tenants of the building have already spoken out in other areas saying that they were not rehoused. The Broadway plan does not demonstrate an adequate way and how the city is expanding infrastructure, such as schools, hospitals, sewers, hydro lines that meet the density that is being proposed with the amount of high rises. Unless, of course, the units are meant to be lived in by single people without families or left as untenanted investments. I ask that you make an amendment to the approval process that the developer must show evidence that they have a comprehensive plan for rehoming the residents and units. The units must be at the same size and the same bedrooms to what is currently tenanted as the majority of the residents are living multi-generationally in two to three bedroom family units. Please guarantee that the families can continue living together, as currently there is no guarantee that they will be offered units that will be comparable to what they are currently living in. Please vote no to assume change. Stand with the residents and not developers. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Jennifer. We do have a speaker number 12, Andrew Seymour.
I guess we do not have speaker 12 here.
Okay. If there are any additional speakers in the chamber, can you please come forward to the podium? Clerk, are there any additional speakers online?
Yes. Speaker number one, Jane McFadden, is now online. Okay. Jane, please go ahead.
Hi, everyone. Hi everyone, I apologize earlier for not being able to hear me. I have listened to all of the speakers though and I love hearing how near and dear Kitsilano is to everyone's heart. I'm from the Kitsilano Business Association and I'm speaking in support of this. We constantly hear that people want to find a place in Kitsilano and they cannot find a suitable place. especially from our businesses that want their employees to be able to live and work in the neighborhood. That's one of our businesses' biggest challenge. We have 278 businesses, so there's thousands of people that work on West 4th, as you can imagine, that live outside of the neighborhood. I understand what the speakers are talking about in terms of congestion and traffic. But I do think that is just what's going to happen in Vancouver. We do need the prices of affordable housing to go down. And that's just a supply issue for our businesses. Of course, I think it was speaker number two, the pharmacist that's an owner-operator of a business for many years. Of course, our businesses welcome those people. I understand there will be a courtyard that will go directly into the Whole Foods. courtyard onto West 4th. So, of course, the 278 businesses that I represent welcome those residents that will be moving into this building to shop and dine and eat and use the services that we offer on West 4th Avenue. I think that's it for me, but I am in support of this project. It falls within the the Broadway line, and I think we do need the density in our city. When I tell people what I do for a living, I constantly hear, oh, I wish I could live in Kitsilano. It's just too unaffordable, and I haven't been able to find housing there. So I think with increased density, there will be opportunity for people to move into this cherished neighborhood. Thank you so much.
Thank you very much. And we have three more speakers online.
Yes. I believe the next person online is Andrew Seymour. Hello? Hi, Andrew.
Sorry. Yes, we can hear you. Yes, we can hear you. Please go ahead. And can we please restart the timer?
Okay, sorry, I just was unable to get connected before, so thanks for hearing me. Good evening, Mayor and Council. My name is Andrew Seymour, longtime resident of Vancouver. I was born in White Rock, chose to live in Vancouver following my schooling at UBC, and I'm choosing to raise my two boys here. I'll keep my comments brief as possible this evening. We need more family-oriented, attainable rental housing in Vancouver. I know this personally. My family and I had a really difficult time finding a three-bedroom rental in Kitsilano. It really shouldn't be that hard. We spent literally months looking for a home that could meet our needs. We've got two young boys, and the reality is that there's simply not enough newer family-sized rental homes in the neighborhood. We managed to get in the building by our friends leaving a certain condo and got in there in Kitsilando, and without that connection and sort of our friends leaving and sort of finding an angle in, we wouldn't have been able to find accommodation and kits. So that's why I'm really encouraged to see there's three better units in this proposal, along with meaningful commitments to... below-market rental homes, having 20% of the units below market rate, including those three beds, will make a difference for folks being able to live in kits. It's a great spot, really great sense of community, vibrant local businesses, schools, parks. Everything's really walkable, and that's what this offers. um that's traditionally been there and this project supports that so uh mayor council i hope you uh vote all in support of this project this evening thank you great thank you very much councillor montague um okay okay thank you um clerk who's the next speaker online yes we the next person online is adrian tom adrian can you hear us Yes, I can. Can you hear me?
Yeah, we can hear you. Please go ahead.
All right. Good evening, Mayor and Council. My name is Adrienne Tom. I was born and raised on the west side of Vancouver, and I'm calling to offer my support for this application. I used to rent a condo not far from the site, and this was my go-to shopping area, so I know the neighborhood very well. I've seen our city evolve my entire life, and change is part of what keeps Vancouver vibrant and alive. Neighborhoods grow, demographics shift, community needs evolve, and thoughtful change is how we ensure the city continues to thrive for the next generation. I also understand that change can feel uncomfortable, but in this case, it's needed, and I think really positive. This application will deliver more than 200 secured rental homes, including below-market rental at a time when housing availability and affordability are critical challenges. These are long-term homes that will support a mix of residents, including families, which is ultimately the reason I moved further east. If this project was built and ready for occupancy a few years ago, I would have chosen this building over the older condo I rented. I truly hope you support this proposal. Thank you for your time.
Thank you very much, Adrienne. Clerk, there's one more person online. Yes. Next on the line is Jeff Janters. Jeff, are you online?
I am online.
I want to say some words in opposition to this project. Not total opposition, but I just think that based upon what I've heard tonight and what I've seen in the plan, the overall Broadway plan, there are some things that I think still need to be considered. And by the way, I'm not a resident of Kitsilano, but I'm a very frequent visitor to Kitsilano, Kitsilano Yacht Club, Royal Vancouver Yacht Club. I've spent a lot of time in Kitsilano and I've seen a change significantly over the last 15 years.
Some of the speakers have made some very good points tonight. Change is inevitable. The council and the mayor have significant responsibilities when it comes to leading. um there's been comments about the the livability of the area as it has changed over time and i think that one of the most important things that was said tonight was by speaker susan davies when she pointed out that there are a lot of tbds in the plan um i think that is a is a almost a fatal flaw in the plan for instance I would think the plan would want to, when it says we're going to have more parks, be specific about this. Because the livability of Kitswana is going to change dramatically with an influx of people. For instance, we say there's 207 units in this building, but there's not. Because the people that are in the buildings being displaced are going to take some of those 207. So it's less than 207 in total. If we're going to put green space in, I couldn't see any spot about green space in the plan. So a way to say that would be all of the condos and apartments on 3rd Avenue between Arbutus and Vine, all of those people are going to be relocated into this building. Those apartment complexes would be demolished and all that would be turned into this beautiful park. And when you consider the fact that there are other buildings going on how are those buildings going to affect the neighborhood and the need for parks in in the kitsilano fourth avenue third avenue fifth avenue area so there needs to be some more thought it seems on how all of these buildings are going to integrate together to make this a neighborhood that is livable in the future And maybe there's a little bit of self-interest here because one of the places I like to go to is Jackson's on 4th, and it's really hard to get a reservation these days. There are more people coming in. How difficult will it be to shop in all the stores along 4th Avenue with 2,000 new residents over the next several years? So I think my advice is just maybe pause, rethink about how all these buildings can get integrated together. and how all of the things that are identified with TBDs need to be actually addressed before a shovel hits the ground. So I just hope that the council would consider that in their deliberations. Thanks for your time. Appreciate it.
Thank you very much, Jeff. Is there anyone else online? No one else online.
My name is Louis Villegas. I am a Vancouver resident practicing urbanism in Canada and the U.S. for 40 years. Next slide, please. I oppose this proposal as I oppose towers building in the neighborhoods outside the downtown generally. The Broadway plan is the worst plan I've encountered so far in my professional career. Next. And I project this image on... In council chambers, I am left with two impressions. One, on the one hand, there's a consensus of this chart published by Global News accurately diagrams the housing crisis. But on the other hand, the voting record reveals that the party in power is hell-bent on perpetuating the housing crisis.
Next.
Read the same message in the zoning bubble diagrams in the staff report. The financialization of land is being passed off for urban design. Next. Here is proof. The towers in the foreground were all approved here. The urbanism, the architecture, the planning, everything is low class. City making of Vancouver is in a tailspin with towers and slot machines out of control.
Next.
This proposed tower will destroy property values by shadowing the houses across the lane. Is there a legal case to be made by property owners and residents? prosecuting a class action suit against government for loss of property value and reduction in the quality of life. Next. Let your eyes follow the shadows. Residents and walk-up apartments lose. Houses and townhouses lose as well.
Next.
The quality of the public realm is also diminished by tower shadows. Next. Here, the model accurately predicts the right approach to towers. The downtown peninsula is seen in the distance as a tower zone, jutting out into Burrard Inlet. Seen from far, far away, the towers appear smaller and don't block the views.
The lesson is crystal. Keep the towers out of the neighborhoods.
Every tower casts a shadow. We already have canyon streets downtown where the sun doesn't shine anymore. Now Vine Street on the left is lining up for the same result.
Lower left, human-scale structures surrounded and overwhelmed by towers. Behind the foreground towers, human-scale urbanism is surrounded by towers. The wheels are circling, but the profits are still flowing.
Fourth Avenue Village features towers blocking views, towers shadowing yards, parlors, kitchens, bedrooms, and the public realm. Towers blocking the view of the Sky Dome. This is the worst possible urbanism.
Next.
Profits are soaring, sort of. The push is up, not out. Government chooses land inflation, not ecological hub-and-spuck urbanism. hub-and-spoke urbanism where GAAP guarantees affordability to all Canadians. How could it be otherwise when Canada is the largest democracy by land mass? We are not running out of land. Government has run out of imagination and more than a modicum of common sense. Next. We've seen it all before. Both Charles Baudelaire and the Impressionists were in full force during the modernization of Paris. The Impressionists immortalized the towns on the periphery of Paris. Baudelaire immortalized the products of modernizing the city, dubbing them the flowers of evil. Next. Tonight, the party in power and those voting in step betray no interest in ending the housing crisis.
Building the concrete jungle, they do it one tower a town, one vote at a time, one slot machine at a time. In October, next please. In October, the voters face a binary choice. Thank you for the opportunity to speak.
There is one other online, Bailey. I don't know how to say the last name.
Yes.
Thank you. Good evening, Mayor and Council. My name is Bailey Maezga, and I'm a lifelong Vancouverite. For many years, I lived blocks from this site. My childhood home and my apartment were just blocks away. So I know the area very well, and I'm in support of this proposal. While recognizing that change can feel scary, I think this is a great project that will enhance kits and allow more people to join the community. Kids is a wonderful area and we should continue to ensure it remains welcoming and inclusive by encouraging the development of market and below market rentals. So I hope you vote in favor tonight. Thank you.
Thank you very much. OK, this is the third and final call for speakers. If there are speakers for this item, he wish to speak to Council. please call toll-free at 1-833-353-8610, followed by participant code 1061445 before the close of the speaker's list. The phone number will be posted on X and displayed during the recess. So we're now going to take a two-minute recess for any additional speakers to call in or come forward to the podium.
I believe we may have one in the chamber.
Hi, I'm Marissa. I didn't prepare. Can you hear me? Everybody hear me well? I didn't prepare for this, so excuse me. I'm opposed to this. I live and work in Kitsilano. And one thing that's really kind of, you know, we're all coming together on one thing here, and that's that we love Kitsilano. We love the character. We love the heritage. We love the community. We love the walkability. We love the parks and the beach and all of this amazing stuff that is Kits. And I understand the people that are calling in for it who are saying, you know, we want the chance to move back to the community. And I think there's a tasteful way to do that. You know, mid-rise buildings. But why does it have to be 20 stories? Because what these 20-story buildings are really going to do is all those reasons people want to stay and come back, they're not going to be there anymore. They're not going to be keeping people in the area. And it's unfortunate and it's sad. And I've lived here my whole life. And it's been my favorite neighborhood. And it's just devastating to imagine what it's going to look like in the next few years. I oppose this, and thank you for listening.
No, no further speakers, Mayor.
Okay, I'm seeing no further speakers.
no see the public comments uh does the applicant have any closing comments thank you mayor yes i have a few closing comments
Firstly, we absolutely respect and acknowledge those who are currently living on the property who, through this process, should the project be approved, may need to relocate for a period of time and ultimately have the opportunity to come back to this project. I can tell you, as an owner of this property... and having long-term intent as a family to own this property going forward. Our goal is to make this change as seamless as possible and to stand by our commitments through the tenant relocation policy to deliver on that, and we've done so successfully in Vancouver in the past. Speaking to some of the items around logistics around the site, I understand them well. I'm a 15-year resident of Kitsilano. I spend a lot of time, almost obsessively so, in that node with my wife telling me to stop looking at the back lane and figure out how we can resolve and make the condition better. The mid-block connection adjacent to Whole Foods that has been discussed is actually a known amenity in the community that's actually been referenced in an urban design context as precedent in many communities as a successful privately owned public space. And our goal with the mid-block connection that we are proposing for this site and the node we're creating on the north end of the property was actually really to lean in to the success of that space, which I personally have used many, many times over the years and see the community using frequently. We think we can add to that experience as we go forward and add to the vitality of that immediate block. I should also point out that currently the project has no parking and no on-site loading, and there is a very tight wall and fence right immediately at that northern boundary of the lane. This proposal will solve, we believe, many of those challenges, having not only containing all of the on-site expected loading and logistics of this proposal on the property. We're obviously adding parking stalls and we think there will be greater relief in the total width of that lane because of some of the space we will be creating and setting back from, which will add some greater relief than the current condition. And so we do think that this project and the opportunity around the public realm will be significantly enhanced and we think that it will really add to the fabric of this neighborhood and the vitality that is in and around this fourth and vine node. And finally, I should say that we really do pride ourselves in the homes that we create for folks. And we have many in Vancouver, some as recent as high-rises in the Oak Ridge Town Center area that we've occupied. And we have hundreds of very, very happy residents that not only... have expressed their positive experience being singles, families, seniors, all occupying our buildings with a refreshed sense of urban living, being in a new rental building, including below-market units. We get great feedback, and we continue to aim to integrate and make our homes better, and this is certainly something we have an interest in doing on this property. And we do think that the overall commitment of this project to provide 20% below market housing and over 70 homes for families is a meaningful step forward in this community in creating housing supply, which we really do believe is there. And we actually have, through this process, gotten a lot of feedback about how this community has been challenged to create these type of opportunities over the years. We welcome the public commentary this evening, and we believe we can be great stewards of development on this property into the future. Thank you very much.
Thank you very much. Do our team members have any comments?
No closing comments from staff. Thank you very much. Does council have any final questions for our team members? Councillor Domenato.
Yes, thanks, Mayor. Yes, I appreciate the, I don't need to ask about the mid-block connection because that was just addressed in the applicant's closing comments. But I did want to follow up on a couple of points that were raised by speakers. To staff, there was a question raised around the TRPP and adjusting moving allowances comparable to other municipalities. Remind me, I believe the TRPP is under review at present. Is that correct? And when is the timeframe for that to come back to Council?
hi thank you for the question emel norden here with housing regulation um yep staff intend to start scoping for the next trp policy review later this year uh with a report back anticipated to council in 2027. okay thank you so as you're hearing comments coming up um as part of public hearings that will be considered as part of some of that policy review is that correct Yeah, we'll be doing a broad review of the policy to ensure that it's working effectively. Okay, thank you for that.
And then I want to circle back to also a question that was raised.
Current residents do have the opportunity to come back to the proposed new building, but their point raised was if they're living in a three-bedroom townhome now, do they have the opportunity to come back to a three-bedroom home? in future. Could staff comment on that? Because I can't ask the question to the applicant, but under TRPP policy. Oh, sorry.
Yeah, thank you for the question. Sorry, online again. So per TRP policy, returning tenants, if they choose to exercise the right to return, should be offered a unit based on their household size and composition in accordance with national occupancy standards. So it may be that tenants currently in a three-bedroom unit would be eligible for a three-bedroom unit upon return, but it depends how many people are in their household at time of rezoning application.
Okay. Okay. I appreciate that. Okay. I'll pause there. Thank you. Thank you.
Yeah, thanks. Just one more question for me. I'm pretty familiar with the area. I moved from 12th and Maple to 3rd and Arbutus for a while and behind what's now Lululemon Shop, but it was a Midas muffler at the time. So I'm pretty familiar with the area, pretty familiar with that laneway. I wanted to address some of the comments around... the bottleneck and behind the Whole Foods. There's a few things that I was going through with the Appendix B. And I noticed 2.3E, it talks about higher zone lane standards. And I'm wondering if staff could explain a little bit what that means. And I also... see something here in I guess it's I and J talks about the duck banks to meet current city standards and as well as the the standalone lighting poles is are we looking at removing the the utility poles because those are actually in the laneway and I think cause a shrinkage of the width of the lane
for the question counselor we're going to relay that question to carolee our colleague in the engineering department yes hi mayor and council um this is carrie representing engineering so um i think in response to your question about uh the ducting uh that is a standard uh requirement that we require on all development sites and sometimes If there are existing lighting on existing poles, sometimes we do want it on a standalone so it's not sharing on the same pole. Okay, so will those hydro poles be removed or will they stay? That will be determined later. It has part of detailed design to look at the feasibility.
Okay, and is there a bigger setback in the lane? Will it make the laneway wider between this project and the Whole Foods that's to the south?
Yes, I think there is a portion to make it into a standard lane width to meet the city standards.
Okay, and can you just... Higher zone lane standards, is that just all part of increasing lane widths? Is that just a general...
That actually refers to the pavement condition, just to make sure that it can withstand additional, I guess, flows and making sure it's strong enough for the vehicles on top of it.
Okay. Thank you, Chair.
Thank you, Mayor.
Yeah, thanks. A few of my questions have been asked already, but I want to follow up on the laneway as well. Our staff, as part of this process, doing any analysis of the volume of, I guess, traffic deliveries in that laneway as it is today, given the Whole Foods loading zone there?
Hi, this is Carol representing engineering again. And so I'll I think what's been observed is vehicles stopped within laneways, and so those are typically subject to the city street and traffic bylaw that requires spacing requirements and time limits to load and unload.
Okay, but are staff analyzing the traffic flow in the laneways, my question, as part of this process?
As part of this process, we are not analyzing the traffic flow.
And just to follow up on your previous point, are you saying that this is an issue for parking enforcement?
Yes. And stats do indicate that as of 2025 last year, the city did receive three parking enforcement related issues on the lane.
Okay.
Thank you.
Yeah, thanks. Most of my questions have been asked as well. I definitely was curious about the lane. Maybe more on the sort of POP and the throughfare there. I know the applicant sort of talked about that they'd be more adding to the POP, but it sounded from the comment from the strata there. That wasn't the case? That's not how they feel? Do we have any sort of sense of how legal feels about this in terms of, you know, is there any, I'm just thinking, is there any sort of future litigation from the strata around sort of integrating their POP with this new POP?
Thank you for the question, Councillor. This is Stacey McFarland with Legal. It's not, sorry, could you just repeat the question?
Just if there was any, if you guys have eyes on any sort of potential litigation from the strata on that throughfare there.
On the continuation of the throughfare and the use of it?
It's not an issue we've assessed internally. If it's an issue between the two property owners, that would be a private matter between the two owners.
Oh, okay. Interesting. Okay, thanks. And then just – I appreciate Councillor Domonato's sort of question around the TRPP review. That was really helpful to remember. But then just in general in terms of like – just to remind sort of the public around public hearings and how policy is created – Generally, we don't create the policy at public hearings. We can take some stuff away from speakers and then maybe come back later at a standing committee and try and tie up any TRPP loop Is that correct?
Yeah, that's correct.
Thank you, Councillor. Okay. So, Clerk, did we receive any additional public comments since the close of public comments?
No.
Okay. So, Council will now make its decision on the application. Do we have a mover for it? Thank you, Councillor Domenato. Seconder? Councillor Montague? Thank you very much. Council, is there any discussion?
seeing no one in the queue oh counselor or sorry yeah i'll jump on um yeah i appreciate a lot of the comments uh here today from folks uh both in support and against um appreciated the comment about our job it's not easy it definitely isn't um we take we take this very seriously i can say that everybody in these chambers takes us very seriously and um We do have to weigh a lot of different things. For me, you know, the TRPP and below market rentals is something that I really look for. And, you know, it's difficult because we're seeing that kind of definitely with the below market rentals kind of stripped away elsewhere. So when I see it still included, I think it's really important. to highlight that that exists. It's not perfect. TRPP isn't perfect, but it's the best we have, and Broadway planning is quite strong on this. So just in light of that and in light of sort of that we have to take each project, you know, with its merits and how it fits into the policy plan, You know, this does fit in with the plan and the policy that's on books. So I will be supporting it on those factors. We do need below market rentals. I know it's not what everyone wants to hear. And I know, you know, you value the time that you've had in the townhouse. And I know it can't be hard. or can't be easy, so I don't make this decision lately, but I think I will support much-needed rentals in this area. Thanks.
Thanks, Mayor, and thank you to all of the representatives and residents who spoke both on the phone and in person this evening. I want to reflect on a couple of things because I thought one of our last speakers articulated it very well, even though I think she said she didn't come prepared, but just that there was some consensus that people love Kitsilano. I think even for those of us who don't love Kitsilano, we love Kitsilano. It's a bit of a gem in the city. And one of the things I heard, one of the other speakers who I appreciate didn't speak in support was representing that they've been in the city for many, many years and that Kitsilano has changed significantly even in 30 or 40 years since the 70s. And I think that is the challenge we find ourselves in and was alluded to by my colleague of trying to strike a balance of how do we try to preserve some of the wonderful heritage and history and character of neighborhoods, but at the same time, accommodate the demand for people wanting to live in these neighborhoods, newcomers, families. Families was highlighted by everyone on both sides of the fence on this. It was both in the loss of sort of the multi-town homes to the fact that people are looking to live in Kitsilano but couldn't find places and the possibility of having three-bedroom family dwellings in the proposal. And so... It is a challenging decision, and I think that some things were clarified. Some of the speakers have raised some questions. I think some of those were clarified by the applicant. I do think there's value in the work that our staff are doing around the policy review around the TRPP. And so as these issues surface as part of public hearings, they will be considered. And then lastly, I think... What also stood out to me, like Councillor Orr, was in this current market, the inclusionary zoning of 20% below market in these projects is difficult. And I didn't get a chance to ask the applicant about their state of readiness and their financing, the ability to actually deliver this, because we do know sometimes these rezonings come forward and then they don't have the capacity to move them. But that is, I think, a real positive in considering the issues of affordability and the housing costs in this region. And then lastly, I heard very clearly, and we don't always hear this from applicants, is that the commitment and passion in being good stewards and speaking to the success they've had with other projects and tenants, and they take pride, it was noted, taking pride in the work. And I think That also speaks volume for the project. But recognizing there are different perspectives on this, and some people will leave here potentially not feeling satisfied or unhappy with Council, but on balance from what I've heard and reviewed, I think that we should support this, and I'm prepared to support it. I did want to reflect some of those comments at the end. Thank you, Mayor.
Thank you very much, Councillor. Seeing no one else in the queue, Council, I'm now going to call the vote.
Clerk, if you can please take us to the voting screen.
Okay, and that passes unanimously.
So that completes item number one. We'll go to item number two now, CD-1 amendment. CD-1566 East Fraserlands Town Square Precinct, 3575 Sawmill Crescent and CD-1567 East Fraserlands Waterfront Precinct, 8711 River District Crossing and 3522 East Kent Avenue South. Before we begin this agenda item, if anyone believes that they have a conflict of interest, now is the time to declare it. Does anybody wish to declare a conflict of interest? Seeing no one's hands up, the clerk's now going to read the application and the summary of the correspondence received.
This is an application by West Group Properties Inc. to amend CD-1566 East Fraser Lands Town Square Precinct and CD-1567 East Fraser Lands Waterfront Precinct to permit changes in Area 1 of the East Fraser Lands community. Amendments include the relocation of underground parking to above grade, which results in... an increase to building heights on Parcels 19.1, 33, 34, and 35, 36, a decrease to building height on Parcel 30, transferring the affordable slash social housing obligation from Parcel 34 to a standalone site on Parcel 30, transferring the permitted rental density from Parcel 33, 34 to Parcel 19.1, and providing miscellaneous housekeeping amendments to correct the live-work use. Consequential, Amendments to the East Fraser lands official development plan will be required and no changes to the overall density are proposed. The general manager of planning, urban design and sustainability recommends approval subject to conditions set out in the summary and recommendation. The following correspondence has been received since referral to public hearing. 11 pieces of correspondence in support, 29 pieces of correspondence in opposition and zero pieces of correspondence regarding other aspects related to the application. I think it's on a break.
This represents all correspondence received up to 5 p.m. Today
at the end of the registered speakers list and we do have our team members from planning urban design and sustainability here to present the application
I'm the rezoning planner for this application. I would like to note that there is a yellow memo with this application that is requesting to amend the distribution of the floor area between two sub areas in CD1-566.
The East Fraser Lines community, also referred to as the River District, is a 128-acre site located in southeast Vancouver next to the Fraser River. The focus of this rezoning application is related to the undeveloped parcels in Area 1, shown outlined in red, and which forms the mixed-use core of the EFL neighborhood.
The area is governed by the EFL Official Development Plan that establishes policies, design guidelines, housing, and public benefit priorities for the area. EFL is divided into five areas that anticipate subsequent rezoning applications to enable development that aligns with the ODP. The site's proximity to the Fraser River and high water table creates significant technical and financial challenges for below-grade parking construction. These site conditions, coupled with the continued expectations for substantial parking in an area not yet well served by rapid transit, require site-specific responses to enable development in this area to continue.
As noted, the proposal is for an amendment to respond to these conditions by relocating the underground parking to above grade, which results in an increase to building heights for specific towers. Transferring the social housing obligation from parcel 34 to 33 is also proposed, along with transferring the permitted rental density from 33 and 34 to parcel 19.1 and the miscellaneous housekeeping amendments to the live work use. While not anticipated by the ODP, this approach keeps the overall amount of residential and parking levels the same, but avoids the need for very deep excavation to avoid the high water table. A subsequent amendment to the ODP will be required to permit above-grade parking and the additional tower heights. By permitting above-grade parking in this area, there is a trade-off to the building form. This includes changes to the massing of the parcels and reduction in the overall provision of open space with the removal of mid-block connections through the parcels. By moving the density above-grade, the building heights and floor plate sizes are also increased, and an additional tower is added to parcel 34. Area planning goals will be maintained by ensuring that parking is hidden from the street or public plazas by wrapping it with commercial and residential uses on primary streets and maintaining walkable active frontages. Regarding the proposed form, conditions have been included to improve the massing and improve building articulation to limit bulkiness.
Public feedback was received throughout the application review process. Comments expressed support for the mix of housing and uses and recognized that this is a practical approach to achieve development feasibility without adding more density.
Comments of concern were raised regarding the lack of amenities and services in the area, impacts on views and access to sunlight, and impacts on traffic and parking. Regarding amenities and services, a community center and child care center is expected to be delivered in the area, with timing dependent on the completion of the residential developments to assist with project funding. Regarding traffic and parking concerns, a transportation study was submitted and the proposal is not anticipated to increase traffic over the original approved rezoning.
This application is generally consistent with the intent to deliver a range of housing and amenities in the East Fraser Lands area, while addressing site-specific construction challenges related to a high groundwater table and increases development viability. Staff support this application subject to the conditions and are available to answer questions, and I would also like to remind Council of the yellow memo with this application.
Sir, would the applicant like to present the application?
I'm Mayor and Councilman Graham Brewster here on behalf of West Group. We appreciate the opportunity to speak this evening. This rezoning is about one essential thing, keeping River District moving forward, not changing the vision, not reducing parking, not increasing density, but ensuring the final phases of Area 1 can actually be built in today's environment. River District was planned over many years in a very different economic and policy context. Since the original approvals, construction costs have escalated significantly, financing conditions have tightened, groundwater policies have evolved and realities remain complex, and more recently, Metro Vancouver fee changes have driven up costs, materially affecting project viability. At River District, we're building beside the Fraser River with a high groundwater table. Although we successfully managed this for the past 10 plus years, deep excavation is increasingly challenging and at this stage, cost and policy prohibitive. Furthermore, while transit options are improving and will continue to improve through the continual build-out, we as West Group understand River District requires parking far above the by-law minimums. For context, West Group developed projects that provided parking ratios above and beyond the bylaw minimums even before those citywide minimums were reduced. This amendment responds to that reality. By relocating a portion of parking into well-designed podium structures, we reduce excavation risk, maintain our ability to meet market needs for the amount of parking, and improve construction feasibility. Importantly, there is no increase in total density. All approved floor area remains the same. We are not reducing the provision of parking. Instead, relocating parking to a more viable location. All other master plan commitments remain intact. is not about building more area it's about making what is already approved deliverable river district is not a one-off project it's a long-term community that has been built steadily for over a decade through market cycles through uncertainty we've continued to build that continuity matters viable projects get built
an unviable one stall, as we recently unfortunately experienced for the first time in our history at Ardea. And when projects stall, housing delivery slows, retail vitality suffers, and public realm improvements are delayed, including parks and affordable housing sites. Community amenities get pushed further out. This amendment allows the remaining parcels in Area 1 to proceed. It protects momentum, and momentum is critical in a master plan community of this scale. as to the progress towards community amenities, including the community center. The community center is important to all of us. We remain committed to its delivery. To that end, we made significant progress between 2022 and 2025 with a top quality design team, resolving complexities with practical collaborative solutions through the completed PDP process and through to the ongoing DP application, having spent more than 3 million in costs to date. However, The funding structure established at the time of the original rezoning has been materially impacted, particularly by Metro Vancouver development cost changes that were not contemplated at that time. The reality does not disappear with this rezoning. However, viable residential projects are a critical piece of the puzzle to staying on track towards resolving that funding structure together with the city. The community center depends on continued build-out. Continued build-out depends on viable projects. This amendment is therefore a necessary step, a non-ultimate solution, a critical step, though, towards keeping the overall framework intact while we work through the broader financial challenges and get the community center delivery back on track. These changes were not developed in isolation. They were developed collaboratively with staff. The revised form of development maintains total density. There's no new density being added in this rezoning. It does increase height, but only as required to achieve the market required overbuild of parking in this new form. And we've worked with staff to mitigate impacts on public open space. It secures rental housing and preserves social housing obligations. It improves feasibility. And it integrates parking in a way that protects the public realm hierarchy, specifically continuing to provide active retail uses at grade on key frontages. We are genuinely encouraged by the progress made together toward a revised form that continues to play a positive role in the community.
Council, in closing, these master plans have long lives. The plan was adopted two decades ago and has seen many modifications and iterations since then. There are countless policies and codes that have changed, and as those add up over time, the built form must respond accordingly. We've worked collaboratively with city staff on many amendments to the plan over the years to capitalize on opportunities such as CMHC financing for rental housing, securing a standalone site for the community center, and the list goes on. This process has been exactly the same, adapting the built form to suit the market and policy environment in which the project exists in, for the community to continue to grow and continue to thrive. River District has always been built incrementally, responsibly, and steadily. This amendment allows for that steady progress to continue. It enables viable projects, and viable projects enable housing delivery. Housing delivery enables amenity delivery. And that continuity is what keeps the long-term vision intact. We therefore respectfully ask for your support in this rezoning in line with staff's recommendations. Thank you.
Thank you very much. Are there any questions from council to staff or the applicant noting that this is the only opportunity for council to ask questions of the applicant? Councillor Meiszner.
Yeah, thanks. I had a question for the applicant. You mentioned work that's been done to mitigate the impact or like it's less than the impact of the loss of the public open space. Could you speak more to that?
Absolutely. So there's a variety of things we did in the PDP community process to enlarge in some of the public open spaces, specifically in and around the Waterfront Plaza and the community center, and driving a lot of attention to those key areas. The mid-block connections that were envisioned in the original ODP... haven't turned out to be exactly what they were originally envisioned, particularly with some of the engineering challenges. So a lot of what was envisioned as sort of open space courtyards have now become loading courts, lanes, and this type of thing. So our focus has really become on higher quality, larger sort of common outdoor spaces, particularly the ones around the community center. and driving a lot of high-quality traffic to that, including the sort of retail frontages on the high streets.
Okay. Thanks for that. And then can you speak to what's changed in terms of the groundwater conditions or regulations in the area? Because I understand there's towers there currently, and I would presume they have underground parking. Sure. So I'd appreciate more detail on that.
The groundwater policies have evolved significantly over the previous 10 years, and it's become increasingly challenging to excavate into the groundwater and deal with the groundwater through excavation. It's resulted in increasingly complicated methods of keeping that groundwater out and increasingly challenging sort of just... actual realities in meeting those engineering obligations to the point where it's become technically very challenging and effectively cost prohibitive. That wasn't the case when those previous projects were approved.
Okay. Thanks for that. I think that's all my questions. Appreciate it. Thank you.
Thank you, Councillor. Okay, so this is the second call for speakers. If there are any speakers for this item who wish to speak to Council, please call toll-free at 1-833-353-8610, followed by participant code 1061445. Before the close of the speakers list, the phone number will be posted on X and displayed during the recess. So we're now going to hear from the public. Any registered speakers in the council chamber, please come forward to the left podium when your name is called. Phone and speakers will be unmuted when your name is called. Speakers will have up to five minutes to make their comments and should limit their comments to the merits of the application being considered. So our first registered speaker is speaker number one, Philip Ostrohowski.
Hi there, can you hear me? Hi, we can hear you great. Please go ahead.
Excellent, and thanks for pronouncing my name so well. I appreciate it. So good evening, Mayor and Council, and my name is Philip Kostrowski, and I'm a River District resident. I actually have been for nearly 15 years. speaking tonight in support of the proposed amendments to the east razor lines official development plan focused on area one as someone who has watched the neighborhood evolve over many years i understand that the large master plan community doesn't get built at once they're they progress in stages and along the way small adjustments are sometimes needed to reflect the changing conditions To me, these amendments feel like exactly that the practical tweaks that keep the overall mass plan moving forward along the above grade parking and redistribution density between parcels helps ensure sites can actually be delivered rather than remaining stalled due to outdated assumptions around cost and feasibility. I appreciate that the overall vision, density, and long-term intent for River District has remained intact. This proposal doesn't change the scale of the development. It simply adjusts how and where it happens in order to make it more viable in today's environment. From a resident's perspective, what matters most to me is seeing the neighborhood continue to progress towards completion. And every step forward is exciting for residents in the area. For those reasons, I support these amendments and encourage council to approve them. Thank you so much for your time.
Hello, Council and Mayor, thank you for your time. My name is Jennifer Reddy and I live at One Town Center in Vancouver. That is in the River District neighborhood. And I, along with many members of my neighborhood, am opposed to the request by West Group to raise building heights and add above ground parking structures for buildings in the East Fraser Lands. And I'm here to say why. But first I do want to share that we love the neighborhood that West Group has created. It's walkable, it's friendly, There's full of ground businesses and sunlight, and it's developing amenities that gather communities and come together for neighborhood walks and family time and sunny patios. There's a shared sense of community here among residents, but parts of West Group's current proposal will drastically change that neighborhood for the worse. So I'm going to share two thoughts on two major issues with the latest request. Number one would be the building heights. So I live at one town center. It is above the Save-On Foods, for lack of a better descriptor. And parcels 33, 34, and 35, 36 are right in front of us, to the south of us. Russ Group's proposal asks to raise these building heights a minimum of 140% over the original building heights when we bought. And let me elaborate. So 33 and 34 already went from 14 to 22 floors in 2022. Council approved this height increase. Now West Group's proposal requests an increase to 34 stories. So that's actually 142% over the original proposal. And that's 20% or sorry, 20 floors over that original 14. Parcel 35, 36 is also in front of us. It went from nine to 16 stories in 2022. Council also approved that. Now West Group is requesting for 22 floors, 144% increase from the original nine. So the city has been very generous with West Group and they approved the height increases in 2022. But these additional increases feel like a bait and switch for those of us who had faith in West Group and bought early into this environment. And the question becomes, so what? Who cares? We do need to make sure that this is a viable neighborhood. The shadow studies that the West Group company did perform show clearly that if these additional heights are granted, The neighborhood is essentially dark for the majority of the day. Those family walks, the sunny patios, the ground-level businesses, a lot of those will go from light to darkness for the majority of the day, and it feels like it's no longer the neighborhood we were promised. It reduces space in West Group as a company, and I think additional consult is needed. I did say I had two issues, so I will get on to my second one now. The above-ground parking. I think that this is tough. 19.1, that's the other parcel. That's to the east of us. Then 33, 34, 35, and 36, again, directly in front of us. This is original plan for underground parking structures. I understand that this is no longer feasible, but it'll drastically, again, change the... ground level experience for us, for those walking by, and it'll further raise the heights of these buildings. So I think we can all agree that walking past a parking garage is not the same as walking past a business or a residence. It'll destroy the ground level experience for us. There was mention of key frontages. We do not know what that means. That's not in the plan. That would be great to know more about. But essentially, you know, I've mentioned over 140% increase in heights. That will be even more if these parking structures are included in that additional height increase. So even in the case of building 9.1 or parcel 9.1. That's to the east of us. There's already significant traffic issues in the lane shared with 3557 Sawmill Crescent. There doesn't seem to be any plan to ameliorate that or to make sure that that traffic does not get worse. And so, you know, that additional height is a real concern for us. And, you know, it's dead streets and tall buildings. And that's not the environment that we hoped for when we bought in the early 2021-2022 timeframe. Final notes. This will severely affect our enjoyment of the homes we've all really purchased in good faith from West Group. The neighborhood was built with a mix of densities in mind, and it feels like West Group... is trying to maximize profits over the vision and livability of the neighborhood for residents. Again, kind of feels like a bait and switch. So we do oppose West Group's application specifically for higher building heights and above ground parking in parcels 33, 34, 35, 36, and 19.1. We don't really want to live in a dark lifeless neighborhood where the sun is blocked and above ground parking present on every block as is proposed. We want to live in a neighborhood we were promised when we put the faith in the city and in this developer.
Hi there. Good evening, Mayor, Council. I assume everybody can hear me.
Thank you very much. Yes, I'm president of a hospitality company by the name of Gooseneck in Vancouver. We operate half a dozen restaurants around the Lower Mainland, and we have two restaurants uh right in the heart of river district uh by the name of uh buffalo and lucky taco uh we've been down a river district in the community since we opened the restaurants back in early of 2024 and uh just been part of the been part of the community watched the area grow into a vibrant neighborhood we would like to express our strong support for the proposed amendments to the Area 1 development plans. From a business perspective, the amendments are pretty crucial to ensure that the master plan community continues to be fulfilled and developed as intended in the way that we understood them to be when we first began these conversations with West Group and the community back in 2022-23. I think the success of the area is ultimately a partnership between the residential and commercial sides of the community. Obviously, the more parcels that are developed, the more residents there are to bring life and energy and foot traffic to local businesses like ours and so many others in the area.
Pedestrian activity, vibrant streetscapes, thriving local businesses, they all feed off of each other in a symbiotic way. Residents support businesses, businesses create destinations. and amenities for residents and those who choose to visit the area, which is obviously an essential aspect of what the parking point brings. And we understand the amendments don't propose any new density, but rather adjust the original plan to ensure viability and continuity of the master plan. This keeps the project on track in the way that it was intended and the way that we understood it to be. It shows the vision for a river district can be fully realized. Ultimately, we think and believe that these amendments mean more residents and more visitors and a stronger, livelier neighborhood, which ultimately is just a key part of that symbiotic relationship, an excellent place to live and provide services in the way that businesses like Goosenecks can and hope to continue to do. in the years to come. And I guess for that reason, we just look forward to seeing the remaining parcels developed and to continue to be able to serve the community for many years to come. Thanks very much for your time.
Is Tina there? Yep. Hi, I'm here.
Can you hear me?
hi okay thank you for your time thank you for letting me speak today i'm also a resident of the river district and i live in mode in fact i'm sitting in my living room right now looking at the development that we're talking about and i've been watching this be built over the years um you know i was also one of the first owners here and you know i love this neighborhood i love what you know it's about community and it's brought a lot of interaction among the neighbors. And like the previous lady was saying, you know, with the increase in building heights, unfortunately, we will be living in darkness. I live on the fifth floor. The proposed building in parcel 30 is six floors. I think the proposed height is six floors, so that will obstruct my view altogether. The
main points that i would like i oppose some and i support some so i oppose relocating the underground parking to above grade um you know which was said already because we all like to look at storefronts and you know other beautiful things as opposed to a garage um and that relocating the underground parking will result in increase to building heights parcels 33, 34, 35, and 36, which the other speaker already said would cause a lot of darkness in the neighborhood. That would result in reduced enjoyment of our properties and our homes. I do support relocating the underground parking to above grade, which results in an increase to parcel 19.1, which won't block some of the views facing the river. I support the decrease in building height on parcel 30, as you can imagine, since I'm looking straight out at it right now. And I do oppose the transfer of the affordable housing, the affordable social housing obligation from parcel 34 to the standalone on parcel 30. I would just prefer to allow people who purchase these units to inhabit. So I don't know if this is for renters or for owners, but I would think with the limited amount of properties in Vancouver, it would be nice if people who bought the properties were able to enjoy it. And that is it for me. Thank you for your time.
Can you hear me?
Awesome. Good evening, members of council. My name is Stephanie Fan, and I am a longtime resident of River District in South Vancouver. The community is extremely important to me because it's where I live, work, and spend all my time, and I'm extremely invested in its future. I really want River District to evolve over time from an industrial area into the current, growing, vibrant neighborhood. It's really taken years of thoughtful planning, consultation, and steady progression to get... to where it is today, and I look forward to seeing the potential of this vision fully realized. I'm here tonight in support of the proposed amendments to Area 1 because I see them as practical adjustments that will help keep the overall master plan moving forward. To my understanding, there's no new density being proposed. Rather, it's being redistributed and parking is being relocated to help ensure the project remains viable so development can continue as intended. As a River District resident of 20 years, I really know firsthand the difficulties of living in the neighborhood, lacking accessible community amenities. At just 12 years old, without a bus route available, every day I would walk to my closest elementary school from River District. As cars raced by, I would be walking along busy Marine Drive with my younger sister in hand.
to Oppentheimer Elementary, which was the closest elementary school, was a total of 40 minutes, and that is a task that no vulnerable child or anyone should endure. For my neighbors and fellow residents, the progression of the master plan directly relates to the delivery of the necessary accessible community amenities. When we can move development forward, it really pays the way for all of us, improving transit and future community amenities that make a neighborhood complete. I'm speaking tonight to ask Council to support these amendments so River District can continue progressing towards completion and delivering the amenities our community desperately needs. Thank you so much, Council, for your time and consideration.
Daniel, can you hear us? Yes, can you hear me? We can hear you great. Please go ahead.
Great, thank you. I'm a longtime banker resident and I still spend a lot of time sort of all over the city and have friends that live down in the River District and I just kind of started to figure out about this project and I just want to speak in support of it. We all know that the viability of a new development and housing are really, really strained. I'm lucky. I got into the market, and I really like to see people continue to be in the market. I think it's really important to keep this development going or else prices might spike again. And from what I understand, that housing along the river is incredibly costly, and building underground is even more so. So I think it would be really great if you could support this and keep housing moving along for everyone. Thank you very much.
Thank you very much. Okay. If there are any additional speakers in the chamber, please come forward to the podium. Clerk, are there any additional speakers online?
We do have an unknown speaker.
Yes.
Yeah, I can hear you.
Great. If you can please state your first and last name for the record and whether or not you're a resident of Vancouver, please.
Yeah, Nathaniel Stewart, and I'm a resident of Vancouver.
Good evening, Mayor and Council. My name is Nathaniel Stewart, and I'm a resident of Vancouver and now lucky enough to be building my life in this wonderful city with my wife and our family. So I know you guys have had a a number of long nights lately so i'll try to be brief delivering new housing and community amenities has become increasingly challenging in today's economic climate i think we all know that at the same time we know that when projects stall the consequences are felt later through reduced supply and rising costs Building along the riverfront comes with unique and significant costs, and I appreciate the creative thinking behind relocating a portion of the underground parking into the podium in a way that is discreet and integrated into the design. Adjustments like this can definitely make a meaningful difference in ensuring a complex master plan community continues to progress. For those reasons, I support these amendments and highly encourage council to advance them. I appreciate the time tonight, and thank you, everybody.
Thank you very much.
This is the third and final call for speakers. If there are any speakers for this item who wish to speak to council, please call toll-free at 1-833-353-8610, followed by participant code 1061445. Before the close of the speakers list, the phone number will be posted on X and displayed during the recess. So we're now going to take a two-minute recess for any additional speakers to call in or come forward to the podium.
I'm not seeing an in the chamber and no for the online.
Thank you. Seeing no further speakers, the speakers list is now closed. Has there been a large volume of public comments received on this item since 5 p.m.? No. Okay, seeing that there are few or no public comments received after 5 p.m., I'm now going to close the receipt of public comments. Does the applicant have any closing comments?
Yes, thank you very much.
I think the comments that we received from the community as a whole in support and as against, I think we're telling a story, and I think Jennifer said it well when she started with why, and part of that why being that they love the neighborhood. I think we too love the neighborhood, and I think West Group comes at it from a different lens. Being a master plan developer with a plan that we have been building or have been planning for more than 20 years, building for more than 10 and intend to be building for decades to come, we too really care about these things. And we too have an immense investment in this community as a whole. We continue to own and operate the retail. We put an immense amount of energy into curating that retail so that it's the best experience for the residents of the community, both the ones that are there today and the ones that are going to be there in the future. that comes with a sort of real practical adaptability that we approach the master plan with. And the previous additions of density and height that were mentioned, those things were for a practical outcome, for a community-focused outcome. That 2021, 2022 was to fund the community center. Why we're here today is to effectively do the same thing so that viability continued to allow these projects to progress and so that we can continue to build out the community. When we build out the community, when we think about what we're doing, we too care about all these things. We care about the retail frontages. We care about the active streets. We care about the public open space. We care about the residents' experience. Those are things that we hold dear, and we have the unique ability to take in the feedback to date and inform the continued build-out for the greater success of the community. We look forward to doing that with staff, with council, for many decades to come, and we appreciate your consideration of this matter.
I just want to remind council about the yellow memo that needs to go with this application.
you. Does council have any final questions for team members? Noting that there are no additional questions to the applicant, at least they're not permitted. Seeing no one in the queue.
If you give me one sec here. Clerk, did we receive any additional public comments since the close of public comments?
Okay. I will remind Council that we need to move the recommendation for item number two, together with the yellow memo dated February the 23rd, 2026, entitled CD-1 Amendment, CD-1-566 East Fraserlands Town Square Precinct, 3575 Sawmill Crescent and CD-1-567 East Fraserlands Waterfront Precinct. 8711 River District Crossing and 3522 Kent Street Avenue. Council will now make a decision on this application. We do have a mover in Councillor Montague.
Second with Councillor Meiszner. And just for clarity, we have a mover for the recommendations with the yellow memo. So, Council, is there any discussion? Seeing no one in the queue, I'm going to call the vote. Clerk, can you take us to the voting screen? Council, please register your vote on the voting panel.
Councillor Frye, this is an honour. Thank you very much. Okay, and that passes unanimously. Thank you very much.
That completes item number two. Thanks, everyone. Okay. Item number three, CD-1 rezoning 1030 through 1070 East Hastings Street and 1115 through 1129. East Hastings Street and 360 Glen Street and 1168 through 1182 East Hastings Street. So before we begin this agenda item, if anyone believes they have a conflict of interest, now's the time to declare it. Seeing no one declaring one, we're going to move on and now hear the clerk read the application and summary of correspondence received.
This is an application by West Bank to rezone three non-contiguous sites at 1030-1070 East Hastings Street, referred to as East 1 site, from M-1 Industrial District to CD-1 Comprehensive Development District to permit the development of a 37-story rental residential building containing 382 units and commercial space on the ground floor. A floor space ratio FSR of 16.0 and a height of 112 meters, 368 feet are proposed. 1115-1129 East Hastings Street and 360 Glen Drive refer to as East 2 site from M-1 Industrial District to CD-1 Comprehensive Development District to permit the development of a 39-story rental residential building containing 385 units and commercial space on the ground floor. A floor space ratio FSR of 23.2 and a height of 116 meters, 381 feet are proposed. And 1168-1182 East Hastings Street referred to as East 3 site from M-1 Industrial District and RT-3 Residential District to City 1. comprehensive development district to permit the development of a 19-story social housing building containing 157 units and commercial space on the ground floor. A floor space ratio FSR of 10.3 and a height of 56 meters, 184 feet are proposed. The general manager of planning, urban design, and sustainability recommends approval subject to conditions set out in the summary and recommendation. The following correspondence has been received since referral to public hearing. 16 pieces of correspondence in support, 36 pieces of correspondence in opposition, and 5 pieces of correspondence regarding other aspects related to the application. This represents all correspondence received up to 5 p.m. today.
Thank you very much. This is the first call for speakers. Any speakers for this item who wish to speak to counsel, please call toll-free at 1-833. 353-8610, followed by participant code 106-1445-POUND. Before the close of the speakers list, the phone number will be posted on X and displayed during the recess. There will be an opportunity for new speakers and missed speakers to be heard at the end of the registered speakers list. We do have team members from Planning, Urban Design, and Sustainability here now to present the presentation.
THANKS, MAYOR. GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL. MY NAME IS NICK DANFORD AND I'M THE REZONING PLANNER FOR THE FILE. THIS APPLICATION IS FOR THREE SEPARATE NONCONTIGUOUS SITES EACH OWNED BY A DIFFERENT OWNER AND IS PRESENTED AS A COMBINED ALL OR NOTHING REZONING PACKAGE. Given the dependencies between the sites, staff have prepared the report and associated bylaws on the assumption that the rezonings will be considered at the same meeting. Staff are not obligating Council to enact all rezoning bylaws, but do recommend that all three sites move forward together due to their interrelated nature.
The proposals include three separate sites along East Hastings Street. The first, labeled E1 or East 1, is a vacant site zoned M1 Industrial and is located on the southwest corner of the intersection of East Hastings and Glen Drive, adjacent the railway to the west. The second site, labeled E2 or East 2, is also zoned Industrial and is located on the northeast corner of the same intersection. The site is currently developed with two single-story industrial commercial buildings. The third site, labeled East 3, is split-zone industrial residential and is located on the south side of East Hastings, just to the west of the intersection of Hastings and Vernon Drive. The site is currently developed with a single-story vacant commercial structure. In the summer of 2025, a fire destroyed the three-story vacant single-room occupancy or SRO building that previously occupied the site. There are no residential tenants on any of the three sites. A mix of uses and forms are within the surrounding area. Properties along East Hastings are generally zoned M1 and developed as one- or two-story commercial or industrial buildings. Properties to the north of the sites are namely industrial uses and developed with low-rise buildings, while properties to the south are zoned RT3 and generally developed with single detached houses, duplexes, and multiplexes.
The sites are located in the Hastings East sub-area of the Downtown Eastside Plan adopted in 2014. The policy anticipates redevelopment in this area to allow for residential and commercial uses up to a density of 6.0 FSR and height of 36.5 meters or 120 feet, equating to approximately 12 stories. Additionally, in July of 2022, Council directed staff to consider rezoning applications for the redevelopment of the subject sites, allowing for additional height and density in order to deliver new secured market rental housing with a minimum of 20% of the overall units as social housing, as well as any additional public benefits. At the time, the concept design included maximum densities between 10.7 and 16.7 FSR and heights between 19 and 27 stories.
So here's a closer look at each site. First up, we have East 1 at 1030 to 1070 East Hastings Street. East 1 is proposed to be a 37-storey rental residential building containing 382 units with commercial uses on the ground level. A total height of 368 feet and density of 16.0 FSR is proposed. The table on the screen compares the proposal with the height, density, and key urban design considerations contained in policy and as submitted in the policy inquiry concept design in 2022. Staff note that the use is consistent with the policy and previous iterations. However, the proposed height and density is greater than previously anticipated. Additionally, the proposed railway separation is less than what is required. Regarding the railway separation, conditions have been included in Appendix B of East 1 to ensure that the development will adhere to the minimum rail mitigation measures required for developments adjacent railway line.
Next, we have East 2 at 1115 to 1127 East Hastings and 360 Glen Drive. This site is Kitty Corner, East 1, and is proposed to be a 38-story rental residential building with 385 units and commercial units on the ground level.
The total height of 381 feet and density of 23.2 FSR is proposed. Likewise, with the last slide, the table on the screen compares the proposal with the height, density, and key urban design considerations and policy, and as submitted in the inquiry concept design. Staff note that the use is consistent with the policy and previous iterations. However, the proposed height and density is greater than previously anticipated. Additionally, the proposed tower setbacks to future residential and industrial buildings are proposed to be 25 and 17 feet respectively, compared to the 40 or 30 feet anticipated in policy. Regarding tower setbacks, conditions have been included in Appendix B of EAST-2 to ensure the appropriate tower separation is achieved through the development permit process.
Lastly, we have East 3 at 1168 to 1182 East Hastings. This site is located a half a block further east from the other two sites on the south side of East Hastings. The proposal here is for a 19-storey social housing building containing 157 units and provides commercial space on the ground level. A total height of 184 feet and 10.3 FSR is proposed. This building consists entirely of studio and one-bedroom units, which will be targeted primarily to seniors and persons with special needs. This site is owned by the Provincial Rental Housing Corporation, or PRHC, which is a corporation associated with BC Housing. Similar to the two previous slides, the table on the screen provides a comparison of the proposal with the inquiry and policy. Staff note that the use and tenure were previously contemplated, as well as the height and density in the inquiry process. However, the proposed density and height do exceed what is contemplated in the plan. Additionally, the proposal includes 17% of the overall residential units for all three sites as social housing, where 20% was anticipated in Council's 2022 direction. The applicant has indicated that this is the maximum amount of social housing that can be delivered while maintaining overall project viability. Staff understand that the applicant and PRHC have agreed that if the rezoning is approved, the applicant will construct the social housing building on behalf of PRHC. However, the city is not party to the specifics of this agreement. PRHC will own the building and lease operation to a non-profit housing provider. Conditions of enactment have been included in Part 2 of Appendix B for East 1 and 2 to require the registration of a covenant in order to restrict the issuance of a development, building, and occupancy permit for East 1 and 2 until the corresponding permitting has been issued for East 3, the social housing building.
Public input was collected through the application review via the online comment form, an in-person information session, and online question and answer period. Responses in support of the proposal supported the new rental housing, the proposed density and form for the neighborhood, and the potential for growth and revitalization of the neighborhood once the buildings are constructed. While concerns were raised about the proposed height and density in relation to the existing plan and surrounding built context, the strain the additional density may put on local amenities and the lack of transit and green space for the neighborhood. In response to concerns, staff recognize the proposal exceeds the height and density anticipated in the plan and previous iterations. However, on balance, if approved, the proposal will deliver over 750 new rental housing units and over 150 social housing units. The site is located along the R4 rapid bus route along Hastings Street, and the city is in regular contact with TransLink and the Vancouver School Board in order to coordinate services. Finally, neighborhood amenities such as community space can be determined through the city's capital planning process.
The application is subject to a negotiated CAC process. Staff have reviewed the application, including the cost of securing the rental and social housing, and have determined that no CAC is expected. East 1 and 2 sites are subject to the public art contribution that is estimated at just over $1 million. It is anticipated that the project will pay DCLs of approximately $16.5 million. As the floor area in East Threeside is dedicated to social housing, it is exempt from the DCLs and not subject to the public art policy. The total public benefits is approximately $17.5 million, with additional benefits coming in the form of rental housing and social housing units that would be owned by a public agency.
SO STAFF RECOGNIZE THAT THE PROPOSED HEIGHT AND DENSITY SIGNIFICANTLY EXCEEDS THE EXPECTATIONS OF THE PLAN. THE RESULTING BUILDING FORM, SCALE AND MASSING WILL HAVE IMPACTS ON THE URBAN DESIGN PERFORMANCE, INCLUDING CONTEXTUAL FIT, PUBLIC REALM PERFORMANCE, UNIT LIVABILITY AND FUTURE DEVELOPMENT POTENTIAL. In response to these impacts, staff have included conditions in Appendix B requiring design improvements to the on-site public open space, the tower setbacks, and architectural expression to help mitigate these building impacts. In conclusion, despite the urban design challenges, on balance, given the proposal would deliver over 750 new rental units and over 150 new social housing units to be owned by a public agency, staff do support the proposal subject to conditions outlined in Appendix B and are available for questions. Thank you.
Would the applicant like to present the application?
Thank you. We don't have a presentation tonight, but I just wanted to share a few words. My name is Mahmoud Biazi. I'm with West Bank, and I'm pleased to be here on behalf of the project team, East Village.
First, thank you, Mayor and Council, for your time and consideration this evening. We respectfully ask for your support of our proposal. I would also like to thank staff for their time and detailed presentation this evening and for their diligence and thoughtful guidance over the past several years. This has been a thorough process and the proposal before you tonight is better because of that process. As presented, this is a three tower project in the Hastings East area of the Downtown Eastside Plan, which has not seen much activity since its adoption in 2014. Our proposal will deliver 924 new secure rental housing units with 157 of those designated as social housing on a standalone site. This development will accomplish the mutual objectives set out by the City of Vancouver and BC Housing. It will provide current and future residents with access to new purpose-built market and below-market rental homes with secured affordability, which is critically important given the urgent need for balanced rental housing projects that sustain socioeconomic diversity and support new residents as well as people who already call this neighbourhood home.
With our shared history and continued investment in this community, together with our partners, we are excited to move this meaningful project forward. Members of the design team are here to respond to any questions or feedback you might have. I'm also joined by Vice President, by BC Housing Vice President of BCBuilds and CEO of Promerida, our partners in this project.
Thank you.
Good evening, Mayor and Council. Thank you for the opportunity to speak today. BC Housing, through its Provincial Rental Housing Corporation, which is the land holding arm of BC Housing, is in partnership with West Bank and Palm Merida Group. And we've been in partnership with them for over six years on this site. And we long await this potential rezoning so that we can get rental housing in this much needed area and without the support of this council and the great work of the city staff we are afraid that the current land agreement that we have with the owners will ultimately expire and we will have to dissolve our relationship which means that we Will not be moving forward with our portion of the site. So just wanted to put that in context So, thank you very much Thank you very much.
Are there any questions from council to our team members or the applicant knowingly? Noting that this is the only opportunity for council to ask questions of the applicant. Yes, councillor Dominata.
I'm sorry Yeah, I'll just launch into my questions I'm Where am I going to start? Maybe to the applicants first.
Given the, between the three towers, the substantive number of homes and units, and as noted, BC Housing being a partner, what is the state of readiness to be able to, we've been seeing applicants come here and then nothing gets developed for years. Is there a readiness with, and I'm following the provincial budget and conversations there, to actually finance this and deliver. I don't know if you can speak broadly to that.
Thank you for the question. We're absolutely ready and would like to be in a place that we start shoveling the ground by end of the year. We're working very closely with all levels of government right now. They're in support of our application. And we're working with all levels of government to... DETERMINE THE APPROPRIATE FUNDING THAT CAN BE ACHIEVED FOR THIS PROJECT. THERE IS A SERIES OF DIFFERENT PROGRAMS THAT ARE AVAILABLE, BC BUILD AS WELL AS BUILD CANADA HOMES. THOSE ARE THE FUNDINGS THAT ARE AVAILABLE PROVINCIALLY AND FEDERALLY AND WE'RE WORKING WITH THOSE AGENCIES ALREADY TO MAKE SURE WE GET THE PROPER FUNDING FOR THE PROJECT.
Okay, thank you. One other question, because I want to get to staff, is just around, I just heard from the report that it's at the DP stage that parking would be determined. Do you anticipate parking being included with this? It's quite a large number of homes, and we know that TransLink's looking to remove street parking in areas along East Hastings to accommodate more best rapid transit. I don't know if you could address that question as to what you might contemplate for parking.
Sure. The project already does include a number of parking spaces.
Give us a sense of how many?
Yes. Altogether, there is about 45. The project ultimately will be meeting the requirements of the parking bylaw.
So 45 parking spots for all three buildings?
There is. The demand that we see for rental housing, that's what we see right now. That's required, and that's what's been proposed. But we'll be meeting, ultimately we'll be meeting the requirements of the Vancouver Parking By-law.
Right, in terms of minimum.
And the project, obviously, as was mentioned by staff, it has access to different public transit and rapid bus lanes as well, with very close proximity to downtown.
Yes. Okay. Thanks. I want to go to staff. I want us to go circle back with the rail distancing guidelines. I just want to be really clear when you reference the conditions that, in fact, right now it's at 22 feet. Maybe it's at 22 meters.
22 meters.
It would meet the 30 meters minimum guidelines?
So there's guidelines from the FCM, is it? Yes, FCM guidelines. And so they would be required to meet that. There's a condition in Part 2, Condition 2.16, which is a covenant that would require they meet those guidelines. Maybe the applicant can speak more about how they intend to meet that at the time of DP, but we're requiring it through those legal conditions.
To meet the 30 meters.
Or an engineered solution is very capable of doing that.
Maybe the applicant wants to speak to that because it's a really big concern. We're encroaching on and we lack big antique. I know people haven't forgotten that. So can you speak to that in a bit more detail?
Yeah, so the guidelines are for 30 meters for the setback because it's a main line there. There are provisions that that setback can be reduced with the introduction of a crash wall to mitigate any measures of, like, train derailment. So we've been in contact with CN Rail with those mitigation measures that would be reviewed by CN Rail and ACOM. to meet the safety standards, not just with train derailment, but also the acoustic noise vibration. That would all get reviewed. So CN Real have said that, yes, we can, with the necessary measures, we can go down to 15 meters with that setback.
Yeah.
Okay, I have another question. I don't know if I'll try to squeeze it into staff. Thank you for that. The neighborhood context recognizing, so east of Clark, there is other properties, some I think privately held, others maybe by the city. There's future development contemplated. What is under our city of Vancouver plan that's coming, what is allowable there in terms of density and heights east of Clark? Because this would be quite precedent setting. And maybe someone of my colleagues will maybe pick that question up for me. Thank you.
Yeah, I wouldn't mind hearing the response to that question. I'm thinking of the Waldorf. Is it the Waldorf? Yeah. what would be allowed under the Vancouver Plan east of Clark?
Yeah, so I'm going to have to look at a map for east. I know in this area for Vancouver Plan, the designation is for, I believe it's 12 stories, but I can circle back and find out what's the designation for the east side of Clark. Okay.
And for this area under Vancouver Plan, what is it?
12 stories.
Okay, and that's the forthcoming Vancouver Plan.
That's right.
Okay. Okay, thanks. I'm curious for staff as well. Are there any other examples of buildings of this height proposed or under development that are not on rapid transit?
There are like 38 stories. I can't think of any. I'm trying to think of...
We'll have to have a ponder over here. I don't believe there are. Nothing comes to the top of mind, but I can definitely have a look over.
Okay. Thanks for that. And then can you explain, I guess, the three different parcels? Is it three different landowners as well? Yes, it is.
Okay.
Is this an unusual situation to have something like this come forward, three different parcels, three different landowners? I presume it's permitted because it's coming to us, but have we seen that before?
It is unusual, yes. It's not a regular arrangement. Usually it's a single site with a single owner or with multiple interests, but yes, this is unique. Okay. Okay. Thanks.
That's it for staff. Appreciate that. For the applicant, could you speak to... What would be built first if this was to be approved? Which one of the towers?
The plan is to start all of them together, and obviously because the East 3 Tower is a smaller 19-story building, relatively it will be probably finished beforehand. But there is a condition in the rezoning piece that requires us, even before development permit, we'll have to have the development permit for East 3 before we can go ahead with the rest. Okay. I could also speak to your previous question. Sure. Like in terms of land ownership. So the East 1 and 2 are owned by the same, they're two different names, but they're owned by the same entity between West Bank and Promerita. And East 3 was also owned by Promerita and has been since the ownership has been transferred to BC Housing or PRC.
Okay. Thanks for that. Could I ask a question to the BC Housing representative?
Hi. I'm curious, why would you not develop the parcel that you own independently? Why is it dependent on these other two rental buildings?
Because this proposal, as just mentioned by the applicant from West Bank, was not originally owned by BC Housing. It was owned by Pro Merida Group in collaboration with the developer, West Bank. And they proposed the three buildings to BC Housing as a whole, as a portfolio of three buildings coming forward. And we looked at the... a proposal from a three-building perspective. Hence, the relationship to partner was that they would transfer one of those sites, which was done five, six years ago, where BC Housing purchased that one site, which is Living East 3, in collaboration as a partnership. So that's why we didn't do it as a singular site because we didn't own the three properties at the beginning.
Okay, thank you. That's it for me.
Yeah, thanks for the presentation. Some of my questions were asked around the timeline and that sort of unique ownership structure as well. But just to staff, this is a lot. It appears like we're giving a lot away in terms of deviating from the policy, you know, 37 stories instead of 12 for East 1, 38 instead of 12, and then the tower setbacks that were previously talked about. uh, and, uh, you know, 19 stories of social housing, which is great, uh, obviously, but, uh, you know, only 17% for the sort of the combination of the, of all of them instead of 20% of social housing. Um, is there sort of some sort of policy, like what, uh, I'm just trying to get a sense of why that's like this, where we're giving so much away and, and, and, and getting under the sort of 20%, uh, social housing, um, uh, What would a developer normally have to pay for getting this kind of increase in height, up to 50 stories? Is there a standard amount of housing that you would usually have to provide to get this extra density?
I mean, it's a good question. We look to the plan. So the plan calls for 12 stories and would expect that 20% social housing. So that's what the policy calls for. This is not what's been proposed, and the applicant has suggested that it's not financially viable under the plan, as well as this is what's required in order to actually realize the project.
So simply put, it's because these unique three sort of sites, the combination of a number of things in terms of the BC housing ownership, it's just very unique that we're considering this. Otherwise, it would sort of be not giving this kind of increase in height.
Thank you. We might actually turn this question over to our colleagues in real estate who are online.
So I'm Amit from Real Estate Services.
Oh, I have to ask it again. No, sorry. Just a little delay there. I mean, the way the city, I mean, there are the sort of plans and policies. that are approved by council for an area. But when somebody comes with a proposed rezoning, it's not necessarily about there's a certain number or amount to allow what they're doing. We review the proposal in its entirety and we determine if there's any additional land left at that point in time of the rezoning. In this case, we reviewed it and there wasn't. But of course, staff do recognize There are pieces that go outside of the policy.
Okay, thanks. Switching to the sort of deeper affordability aspect of it and realizing that we just recently sort of changed the policy, but there was 36 units of SROs. I couldn't do the math quickly enough on there in terms of the... two-thirds. How many SRO units or deep affordability are we going to get out of this? Are we just doing one-for-one replacement of the 36? Are we going above the deeper affordability there?
I'll maybe turn that over to Amel from the housing group.
Hi, ML Norton with Housing Regulation. I think it's falling just shy of the 36 existing units. I think there will be approximately 34 at the shelter rate.
Okay, so can you remind me of the policy then? I thought it was supposed to be sort of a one-for-one replacement of the shelter rate if there was 36 units of SROs there.
No. That is the typical expectation. My understanding is that now the building no longer exists. There's no SRA permit required. And so the one-for-one replacement isn't required to be at shelter rate. However, they are replacing with more than that amount of units as social housing. So it meets the general expectation of what the policy would be.
Because of the other units. And what are the, just remind, just for the public record, I guess, what's the makeup of that social housing? Is it 30% at Hills?
Yes, 30% at Hills and two-thirds of which must be at shelter, right?
30%. And so, yeah, that term, that just is around 34. Okay. Okay, thanks. That's all my questions for now.
Yeah, if I could follow up actually just on that last point from Councillor Orr about the amount of, so how much below market is this project achieving?
Can we get some more detailed numbers? Because it is confusing with the changes to the Downtown Eastside Local Area Plan and the definitions of social housing.
Yeah, the social housing, so the building on East 3 will be 100% social housing, 30% of which is required to be a minimum of, hills rates, but two-thirds of that is required to be at shelter rates.
So 70% market is essentially what we're saying? Up to market, yeah. Yeah, 70% up to market and then 30% below market. Okay.
Yeah, okay. So, I mean, thank you for that. That's sort of illuminating. It does fall short of, I think, what our expectations have been. Back to... planning staff on on on the the height did you come up with any examples to Councillor Meiszner's question around what is the uh do we have any any uh towers of this kind of comparable height outside of transit oriented areas or outside of the downtown uh thanks for the question counselor we had a chat here and the ones that we were thinking of are the efl sites that were just considered here tonight
Oh, the East Fraser lands there? Yeah. Are they as much as 40? Oh, okay. Well, I believe mid-30s was what was reviewed this evening. Right. Okay. But those are the only examples. Yes, those are the only examples that came to us.
Okay. So... How confident, like in reviewing the sort of performance on this, I mean, they are extraordinary heights and I'm quite familiar with these sites and they've been kind of more abundant. You know, we're routinely passing projects even just today with 20% below market as the inclusionary zoning piece on 20 stories-ish around the Broadway plan areas. Why is this so different in delivering less below market housing and much higher heights and for arguably less valuable land.
Yeah, I mean, perhaps that's a question for the applicant. Maybe put it to the applicant first, and then if there's any follow-up, we can have real estate respond.
Okay. Thanks for the question. One thing I really want to emphasize here is that the East Tree building that is being delivered as part of this project is entirely a social housing building. And so that's 157 units with deep affordability. And I'm sure PC Housing will also be looking to see how they can even deepen these affordabilities from more than what has already been proposed. So 157 units on a separate site and on a standalone site. And normally what you see... in the downtown side or other part of the city, when you see 20%, those units are provided within the building, and those are affordable or social housing or whatnot. In this case, we're providing the entire 157, 19-story building on a separate site, and it is at its own amenities. It has its own... basically called own cost and everything else. And because of that, 17% is the maximum the project could allocate to stay and still stay viable. One other thing.
I could also add to that. There is, since the adoption of the plan in 2014, there has almost been no activity other than the building across the street from us, which is a 12-story fully funded building. a government-funded project. There has been no activity in the Hastings East area of the Downtown Eastside in terms of any rental housing or even social housing other than the one that I mentioned. And part of that is the expectations were too high and obviously the project couldn't deliver.
Yeah, I would say there's a critical, crucial need for amenities there to support that kind of population as well. I'm almost out of time, so I was going to ask staff back to just commenting on some of the urban design analysis, which seems very inconsistent with what the general recommendation is. It seems all these outcomes in the urban design are quite challenged. Can you comment on that at all? The discrepancy between the urban design comments or analysis?
Hi, Grace Jiang, Development Planning. I guess you mentioned urban design analysis in the Appendix E. Is that what you refer to?
Yeah, I I put my name down because I thought the counselor fry was running out of time So please go ahead.
Okay. Thank you Yeah, I'll continue. Um, yes what while we're reviewing the project so we in real stuff realized this proposed the height and density exceeds the expectation of the plan significantly and which really caused some unexpected impacts onto the urban design performance in this area. Those analyses basically focus on those impacts on those urban design performance, including... contextual fit and public performance, public-run performance and unit livability and also impacts on the future developments and the potential of the future developments. And so that's, we realize that's kind of trade-off with the supply of the social housing. And staff also include the conditions in Appendix B. and trying to mitigate those impacts. For example, we request the additional on-site public open space to improve the public realm. Also, we require some design development to ensure the tower separations between the proposed building and the existing building and the future towers to ensure the livability of the units. As well as we are looking at the articulation of the buildings to make sure they contribute to the urban views. Yeah, those are all around those analysis about urban design. Thank you. Oh, sorry. Okay.
Thank you very much. Councillor Maloney, did you have any other questions or help? Not at this stage. Thank you. Councillor Domenato.
I'm hoping you could move a second round because I'm out of time and I have questions.
Thank you.
To staff, can you just comment on state of readiness in terms of underground infrastructure in the area? Again, just given the scale of proposed developments and having looked at some issues in Burnaby where they had to, because they didn't have enough sewer capacity when they were doing some work around Brentwood and so on. Could you just comment on what our capacity is there and are upgrades required?
Sure, I'll refer the question over to Carol from Engineering Online. Hello, Mayor and Council. This is Carol Yee for Engineering. There is existing infrastructure capacity for the development and the area, and so there are no servicing upgrades required.
Okay, thank you. I appreciate that. And then I wanted to circle back to the previous direction from council, which, if I recall correctly, was 20% social housing and Allowance of between 19 to 27 stories. Is that is that correct? And so maybe the questions for the applicant is this What we're seeing here and maybe staff as well responding to market conditions today And maybe yeah, thank you You
Thanks for the question. Absolutely. In 2022, when the project at the time went to council, we were obviously in a different market, and that has drastically changed. Since then, the construction costs have gone up quite drastically, by 50%, 60% in some areas, and the rents have also reduced by 20%, and that very much affected the entire project performance.
And while you're there, that just triggered another question. So if we take the social housing piece out of this component, what would you propose doing for just focused on market rental and below market rental, which is also needed, we know, in terms of our vacancy rate? Would you still be driving at, you know, 39-story towers and so on? What would, like...
I didn't...
I guess my question is this, is it seems that the driver behind this is trying to meet the need of social housing, which is the responsibility of the provincial and federal governments. And so, but if you weren't to take that early equation and just develop the sites you have for rental, market rental, below market rental, what would you do? Would you still be proposing this or you'd be falling more in line with existing policy?
I'm not even sure at that point if there would be a project because... You wouldn't do market rental at all. Exactly. It would be very difficult to make the project work. Having the BC Housing and working with them on the available funding will be very helpful for the entire project. And one thing, too, maybe also something I wanted to maybe emphasize on, the 157 units of social housing is not just the benefits. The 767 secured market rental units are also massive benefits to the neighborhood.
Okay, but I'm just sorry, Mayor, I just wanted to be clear on this point, though, is what I heard, though, is that you wouldn't be looking at doing market rental or at these sites. without this, even though we've had other applications coming forward that are looking to do market rental around the city. But in this instance, wouldn't you just leave them? They just sit?
We'll have to look at the project to see how we can make it viable again. But it would be market if it's not social housing, which is obviously not ideal either. Okay.
I'll leave it there. I know Councillor Fry is on the queue. Thanks.
Yeah. Thanks. Question for Steph before we get into the other ones. But I just noticed that there's articulation in here talking about vacancy rates at 1.5% or 1.6%. I was of the impression that the vacancy rates had jumped considerably up to mid to high 3%. Is this an accurate representation of the vacancy rate?
Hi, I'm Elle Norden with Housing Regulation. Yes, that's right. The vacancy rate at the time the report was written in 2024 was 1.5%, and in 2025, it rose to 3.9%.
It's at 3.9% now. Okay. That is helpful. Yeah, I am struggling with this. This is a question for the applicant, and I realize this is a possibly uncomfortable question, and you certainly don't have to answer anything like this. Obviously, there's been a little bit of news today and over the course of the week around West Bank and financial viability of projects and that kind of thing.
To what extent is the pro forma on this particular project being used to sort of offset other projects? Are we... I would hate to think that we're...
These are absolutely separate projects. There's no relation between this project or any other project. Every project is different.
It is. It's a separate project. Every project is managed. It has its own finances. It's very different. And we're very confident that this project can be delivered. And as I mentioned, we're looking forward to be shoveling the ground before end of the year. We're already working with federal government and with agencies and with BC Housing to secure the financing for this project.
So... Can you speak to why this unique relationship as opposed to just baked in inclusionary zoning and a standalone building? And I understand that you've negotiated this with provincial entity. How did this come about? This seems so unusual to what we typically would approve.
There is a long history of this project. We started this project six years ago. And at that time, we were working with BC. This project was brought to West Bank by BC Housing and Prometer. And given the history that we've had in this neighborhood, we saw it as a great opportunity to provide housing in this neighborhood. And we've been working ever since the last six years on this project with BC Housing and our partners closely to make sure we can deliver it.
Okay, I didn't realize West Bank had a history in the neighborhood. Did you have other projects?
Yes, five other ones, right? The Downtown Eastside plan. There is obviously Woodwards. There is Blood Alley project. There is 60 West Cordova. There's Kiefer in Maine. It's all in the same part of town.
I would argue distinct neighborhoods, but that's okay. Okay. As far as the amenities that will be delivered as part of these three separate towers, can you speak a little bit to that? Because this is an amenity deficient area.
Well, there are DCL and DCC fees that will, about $17 million, $16.5 million that will be given to a city to be spent for all the services that are required in the neighborhood. That could be community centers, libraries, and everything else. I think staff can speak to that in more detail as well. That's obviously in addition to 924 units that this project includes 157 social housing and 767 market housing.
Sorry, say that again. You mean building amenities? Yes. I'll let the architect speak to that in more details.
So since the application, we have been working with staff on some of the amenities. So what you see in the conditions that are part of the report, we are looking at creating more setback at grade. This is to allow for public space, small parklets and plazas for the east one and the east two sites. They're kitty-cornered each other. So we're really looking at adding to the urban environment there from the pedestrian scale. I think within each of the individual buildings, we're also looking at providing quite a lot of amenity space in each of them. So for East 1, it would be over 5,000 square foot of indoor amenity space, over 12,500 square foot of outdoor amenity space. East 2, we'd be looking at similar, you know, quite a lot of amenity space within the buildings. I'm sorry, we're out of time as well.
I've once again logged on to allow the answer to be finished.
Councillor Maloney, go ahead. Yes, we understand there's a lot of density within these buildings, and we think it's really important that the amenities are part of each of the buildings so that we're looking at maximizing livability within each of the buildings. There's also an intent that there's an equality across all three buildings, so that would be for the social housing as well. We're including... rooftop amenities, spaces, multi-purpose rooms, and in-suite storage and those sorts of things. Each of the buildings would also have balconies. So for East 1 and East 2, all of the one bedrooms and above would all have their own private outdoor space. I think that's really important for the livability. And then, yeah, the shared rooftop amenities and then the shared podium amenities in East 1, 2 and 3.
Thank you.
Thank you very much. Okay. This is the second call for speakers. If there are any speakers for this item who wish to speak to council, please call toll-free at 1-833-353-8610, followed by participant code 1061445 before the close of the speakers list. The phone number will be posted on X and displayed during the recess. We will hear from the public. Any registered speakers in the council chamber, please come forward to the left podium when your name is called. Phone-in speakers will be unmuted when your name is called. Speakers will have up to five minutes to make their comments and should limit their comments to the merits of the application being considered. So our first registered speaker is speaker number one, Evan Horry.
Good evening, and thank you for the opportunity to speak this evening. My name is Evan Horry. I'm a Strathcona resident, and I'm here on behalf of the Strathcona Residents Association, more than 500 local residents who have signed a petition opposing the East Village development. Our concern is not about growth itself. We welcome new housing. It's about unbalanced growth. Density delivered without essential infrastructure, services, or amenities required to support the thousands of new residents this project would bring. The proposal calls for towers of 38, 39, and 19 stories containing nearly 1,000 new units, with majority being micro studio and one-bedroom units and only 27% of units allocated for family housing. These heights and this level of density are completely out of context, out of scale, and out of character with the existing neighborhood. Strathcona and Kawasa are predominantly low-rise communities made up of two- to three-story homes of historical significance and light industrial buildings that reflect over a century of human scale development. Introducing towers more than 300 feet tall in the middle of this setting would fundamentally and permanently alter the fabric and identity of our community. But scale is only part of the issue. A major concern is what this development does not include. There's no plans for new parks, no expansion of community centers, no new school capacity, no additional child care, not even commitment to expand basic neighborhood services. The Kawasa area does not currently have a single park within its borders, yet the developer has not proposed any new green space, despite the fact that this part of Vancouver has one of the lowest tree canopies in the city at under 5%. Existing community centers like Raycam, Britannia, and Strathcona are among the oldest and most underfunded in Vancouver. And they already struggle to meet current demand. Adding thousands of new residents without adding services is a recipe for strain on an already vulnerable neighborhood, conflict, and declining quality of life, both for those who live here now and those who might move in. We can't stress this critical point enough. This is not a transit-supported location. There is no rapid transit anywhere near this project. Unlike neighborhoods serviced by SkyTrain where high-rise density is more appropriate, Strathcona lacks the transit backbone needed to absorb this magnitude of growth. Most residents rely on buses that are already over capacity or on street parking which is already limited and heavily used by nearby industrial businesses. Yet the proposed... Proposal includes very limited parking, despite nearly 1,000 planned units, ensuring increased congestion, competition for curbside space, and significant transportation strain. When you add all these pieces together, massive density, high-rise towers out of character with the surrounding homes, no rapid transit, insufficient parking, no new parks and no community services, and no plan to address the needs of families, it becomes clear that this project does not reflect thoughtful or sustainable urban planning. This is why more than 500 residents have signed a petition opposing the development as proposed. These signatures reflect a community that is not rejecting housing. They are rejecting poorly planned development that offers density without livability, height without context, and growth without support. Tonight, we ask council and planning staff for three actions. Reject this proposal in its current form. Two, require meaningful, transparent community consultation before any revised plan moves forward. Three, ensure that any future proposal includes necessary infrastructure, parks, child care, community facilities, transit supportive planning, to responsibly welcome new residents. Strathcona has always supported inclusive community-oriented growth, but growth must be balanced, realistic, and supported by services people need to live healthy, dignified lives. We urge you to stand with our community, acknowledge the concerns of more than 500 residents who have spoken up, and insist on a development approach that respects the scale, character, and infrastructure realities strathcona and kawasa thank you very much uh speaker number two peter sandy uh good evening um so my name is peter sandy i live immediately adjacent to the proposed east 3 site I live at 1220 East Pender. So I wanted to begin by saying that I actually support the delivery of the senior housing. Seniors are among the most vulnerable populations in our housing system, and providing stable housing close to services is really important. However, I think it was mentioned earlier that this application is pretty unusual. and that the broader three-tower package, which exceeds the usual 12-story guidelines in this area and delivers less than the 20% of overall social housing that's usually standard and referenced in this policy, represents a significant deviation from what would be necessary. And so what I would propose is that their senior housing uh is obviously uh an important thing seniors are one of the most vulnerable populations in bc and so that each i don't believe that the east three um though it's been kind of marketed as a senior housing uh development that it actually had some sort of age covenant in it where you where the the age of the that the um the people living in the building would be secured as seniors and i request that it's designated as a uh instead of social housing a senior housing uh uh actual building um and in addition to that i feel like the east three building itself um because its social housing hasn't really had been you know of course there's been mentioned of some amenities to the building uh and and that match or parity to east one and east two but i think the um the the um contributions to the public public realm around the building should be reconsidered um in order to make sure that we're actually lifting up the neighborhood And then the comments that were made previous to me, I think I obviously as a resident of the Strathcona area, I also second that, which is the money that's being given by the development should definitely be restricted to investments in the local community around the space, which includes improvements to public parks, new green spaces, community centers, those sorts of things. and ultimately like the city should really consider this massive amount of justification and how it's actually going to impact the neighborhood and to make sure that it's invested properly in order to kind of handle that um so thank you for that and um thanks for here listening thank you very much uh speaker number three jamie leclerc yes uh can you hear me you can hear you great please go ahead can you hear me Okay, thank you very much. Yeah, my name is Jamie McLaren. I'm a longtime resident of Strathcona. I'm also a practicing lawyer who runs a legal services charity that helps low and modest income British Columbians find access to justice. I speak today in opposition to this application to rezone three sites. at East Hastings and Glen to allow for the development of two, and dare I say, obscenely tall rental buildings and one reasonably tall social housing building. Reasonable is an operative word here because, as you may recall from recent court decisions in West Creek Farms and Langley Township and Kitsilano Coalition for Children and Family Safety Society in British Columbia, municipal councils must exercise their delegated powers in a reasonable manner when considering land use and zoning amendments. A decision of mayor and council is unreasonable when there is a failure of rationality internal to its reasoning process or when it is unsupported by the factual legal constraints that bear upon it. The subject application is being considered on the downtown Eastside plan that was developed after many months of meaningful consultation with diverse members of community and most notably indigenous members of community. It is the governing policy document here, the law of the land, so to speak, and it is rooted in community based principles of equity, inclusion and respectful consultation. This application proposes to bundle three adjacent M1 sites into a single CD1 site of 10 to 23 FSR with three to four times the current height limits. Bundling three sites into a single site of such outsized density removes Council's ability to consider each of the proposed buildings on their own merits as measured against the requirements of the Downtown Eastside Plan. It effectively constitutes a new urban plan for the small but vital area of industrial land and would drastically alter its land use without due public consultation and without due regard for the principles of equity and reconciliation that underpin the Downtown Eastside Plan. consider this application in relation to council's decision in november 2023 to reject more social housing and density in vancouver's shaughnessy neighborhood and ask yourself is it reasonable to so wildly override the constraints of the current downtown east side plan and contradict the proposed constraints of the draft official development plan to achieve massive density gains in one of the poorest parts of our city when you, the same mayor and council, summarily rejected minor density gains in one of the wealthiest parts of our city only a few years ago when the rental vacancy rate was lower? Is it reasonable to so blatantly disregard a local area plan that came from a thorough democratic process and meaningful consultation with community when you find yourself in the waning days of an electoral term and in an age of mandated reconciliation? Is it reasonable to approve such drastic changes in land use without first updating the downtown east side plan or adopting Vancouver's official development plan? Finally, is it reasonable to grant these unprecedented land use concessions to an applicant developer that is already subject to a number of major lawsuits and that appears to lack the financial means to complete its current building projects elsewhere in the city? Cramming so much density onto such small footprints without any plan to reduce the resulting strains of traffic parking, community center usage, and park space usage will noticeably reduce the quality of life for everyone living in Strathcona. This looks like blatant profiteering with a thin veneer. OF SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY. I ENCOURAGE YOU TO CONSIDER WHETHER REZONING APPROVAL SO FAR OUTSIDE THE CLEAR DESIGN PARAMETERS OF THE DOWNTOWN OUTSIDE PLAN WILL BE UPHELD ON JUDICIAL REVIEW. AND I RESPECTFULLY ENCOURAGE YOU TO REFUSE THIS APPLICATION OR SEND IT BACK FOR SIGNIFICANT REVISIONS. THANK YOU.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THE NEXT SPEAKER IS NUMBER FOUR, KAREN LICHKE.
I HOPE I PRONOUNCED HER NAME OKAY.
It doesn't matter. I know you mean me. So, yeah, my name is Karen Litsky. I live in Kawasa, and I'm directly affected by the proposal, along with other local residents. It will basically close off the entirety of the mountain view that people in Kawasa have. You'd be surprised that there is such an amenity in East Van, but it's one of the things that makes... The northeast sector is actually quite a pleasant place to live often. I'm not disagreeing with any of the other grounds that have been raised for opposing the proposal, but I'll start with my comments about the view, which is in effect being expropriated and privatized and monetized. I believe that many of the effects of this kind of a development on unpaid stakeholders are most effectively settled by litigation. And because I'm... to be a plaintiff in this particular situation. I am documenting sort of the closure of our skyline with the expectation of eventually looking at some legal action. I would also like to address the issue of parking. I'm wondering if we can dispense with the utopian fantasy of car-free life or a car-free city. I'm wondering where, if not here, all the Uber drivers are supposed to live. It's also, because it's a light industrial area, the people who work there, these are fairly low-paying jobs for the most part, and they rely on free street parking for the most part. And so that'll just be, there'll be so much competition for that that many of them, I think those companies will be less able to attract employees. Transit is not really a meaningful alternative for people who work in industrial settings. They often need particular equipment that they have to bring to work, and among other things, and also they often eat lunch in their cars. So they lose a lot if they lose their street parking. I'd also like to briefly address what I'm going to call the community amenities game. It seems to me that we've gotten awfully accustomed to discussing community amenities within the context of a developer proposal so that we're not really just discussing the community amenities. It seems to me it's the city's, not the developer's responsibility to provide community amenities and we could have much more productive conversations about them if we simply discuss the community amenity as such. If you want social housing or a community center, bring us a proposal for social housing or a community center. Don't stick us with the 80% that we don't want in order to get the 20% that you want. Since I have a little time left, I'm going to mention two other things. The proposal as I saw it on the website does not show a building that is nearing completion at the corner of Hastings and Glen. There's the red container building and then east of that, directly east of that, there's another building that's, I don't know what it is, 14 stories maybe, that is also already blocking the skyline and darkening the intersection, etc. And I'd also like to make a point about when we talk about park space in the neighbourhood and it being somewhat insufficient. I want to mention that the one open space that we have in Kawasa is the schoolyard. So the Seymour schoolyard is located right in the middle of the neighborhood. And it is the neighborhood dog park. It is the only place that people go to walk their dogs. So basically, the use of the schoolyard features off-school hours, tons of dog traffic with what dogs do, and then that's where the kids play during the school day. So I just want to say, when we're talking about insufficient park space, that's what we're talking about. And I'm sure that a lot of people in a building like this will have dogs, so we're just going to see an escalation of that problem. A dog area might be the biggest amenity that this neighborhood could use. And because I know the area well, I'm prepared to answer any questions about it if people have them.
Thank you very much. Okay. There are no questions. So speaker number five, Claudia Ramke.
Hi.
Yes. I'm Claudia Ramke. I'm a resident of Vancouver. I really support the proposal for the 157. UNITS OF THE SOCIAL HOUSING IN THE EAST 3 BUILDING. I KNOW THAT VANCOUVER HAS A GROWING SENIOR POPULATION AND A LOT OF OLDER RESIDENTS ARE STRUGGLING TO FIND HOUSING THAT THEY CAN AFFORD AND THE SOCIAL HOUSING WOULD MEAN LONG-TERM AFFORDABILITY AND PROFESSIONAL MANAGEMENT FOR THAT PROPERTY.
CAN EVERYBODY HEAR ME ALL RIGHT? SORRY, CAN YOU REPEAT THAT?
uh yes i just wanted to make sure everyone could hear me yeah we can hear you okay uh sorry about that um yeah so i uh think it's a good idea to have that also that it keeps a lot of the senior residents close to services and the new st paul's hospital um so i would ask council to approve this uh rezoning um simply for the uh east three building
I know it includes all the buildings, but that's enough to sell it for me.
Thank you very much. Okay. Speaker number six, Luis Villegas.
First slide, please.
One before that.
My name is Louis Villegas. I am a Vancouver resident practicing urbanism in Canada and the United States for 40 years.
Next slide, please.
I oppose this proposal and I oppose towers outside the downtown generally. Broadway plant and tower sprouting like mushrooms in our other neighborhoods are the worst planning I've encountered in my professional career. Next slide, please. Proof is in the pudding. I don't understand how, in good conscience, professionals confronted with this reality can advise building even more towers. My analysis returns skytrain and towers as the two primary causes of the housing crisis. Next slide, please.
The stuffed bubble zoning diagram hides more than it shows. We don't know the height or the shadows. or how the bulk will affect the sense of place, or how or if the city intends to meet its responsibilities designing the public realm. That is not diagrammed. No streets, sidewalks, trees, or historic Hastings Street designed as a Parisian boulevard operating LRT streetcars between planted tree medians. In our city, street design amounts to making an open traffic sewer, a shallow ditch with cars in it. The yellow arrows on the plan identified the bend on Hastings as a gateway, something missed or ignored in the plan drawn by neophytes. Next slide, please. Besides enriching the boosters and the class in power, Houseman's Paris was a full program for modernizing a city with schools, markets, parks, and boulevards. The trains came in 1900. Next, please. However, there is a fly in the ointment of the 767 secured rental units. and 157 housing units.
One, the quality of the resulting neighborhood where the sun does not get in. And two, the quality of the tiny puny units themselves. Next. Meanwhile, government shows no interest in ending the housing crisis. In a market poised to push affordability 400 times over the median household income, the 20% below market policy amounts to a rounding error. Council's approval of this tower tonight is a vote to extend the housing crisis in perpetuity. Next. This is Pruitt-Igoe-St. Louis, 1972. 157 units of social housing and more in towers were torn down just 20 years after they were built. Why? Well, just look at it.
Next slide, please.
Just look at it. Besides increasing the sense of isolation in the residence, it was found that just one drug dealer sitting in the elevator lobby was able to control an entire building. These are not defensible spaces. Police are trained on SEPTED, crime prevention through environmental design. However, according to their voting record on council, all these concepts seem to have been forgotten. Next.
Like the modernization of Paris, building a concrete jungle out of tower sprawl benefits the supporters of the party in power. I have shown that even when social housing is secured, the quality of the units and the quality of the neighborhood are well below acceptable. The slot machine and the Trout Lake tower votes were transparent. One, Trout Lake was punted until after the election. The same strategy as was used in Chinatown Square, 105 Kiefer, four years ago. Two, hold your nose and pay for your supporters by voting 300 slot machines. More height, more density, less parking, you name it. Next slide, please. Meanwhile, the right answer for Vancouver's urban form can be seen floating in the distance of this slide. Next. Model photos accurately represent how towers in the distance appear smaller and block less of the panorama than towers. in the neighborhoods. Downtown as a tower zone is part of the solution. Next slide, please. Because tower containment is widely accepted as part of GAAP strategies to level land prices in overheated markets. The other part of the solution is building houses below the treetops to keep real estate land prices from taking off.
Next slide.
Put the two parts together and you get this, a clear and simple Part T. a diagram that makes it obvious where the towers go and where their neighborhoods thrive. Next. In October, voters face a binary decision. Thank you for the opportunity to speak.
Mayor Sim, Council, thank you for having me tonight.
Your evening's going well. It is an honor and a privilege to be here on the unceded Coastalish territories of the Musqueam, the Squamish, and the TTsleil-Waututh Nations. My name is Nova. I'm a Cree Welsh woman from the southern plains of Alberta. I grew up here since I was 16 years old in 2002. I'm a Strathcona... I'm a mom in Strathcona community, a person of 18 years... I am a mom, a Strathcona community person of 18 years, rogue outreach, and peer support. I practice in harm reduction. I've been trained in peer support, needle exchange, harm reduction, and outreach before I reached the age of 20. I am in strong opposition of these new buildings coming into our neighborhood. Not only does it look like classism, it screams it. My understanding is that these buildings should be at least 30% of social housing, low-income housing. If appearances were everything, it looks like a poorhouse, a family-style SRO. The segregation only further perpetuates the harsh decline of dignity in the downtown east side, the east end of Hastings, and the separate doors and separate buildings brings further discrimination and segregation energy to my beautifully diverse community. I value the diversity in my neighbors, as well as my children deserve it. This is my community, not division. Our schools, daycares, and programs are already overloaded. What about focusing on what we already have?
RayCam Renew is a project that I've worked on for a number of years with the board of RayCam. I am the former executive president of about eight years. 16 years of being on the board, about eight years of being on the executive. In my time, we accomplished a lot of design and planning, surveys, committee, community input. We surveyed the community. We found what the community wants. All the work that is done, the center is historical. The city had a vote. It was passed. What about what the people want? Parking. There is no parking. We already have, like, we're overloaded. People are struggling. Residents are struggling to even find parking. My husband has to park four blocks away sometimes.
It's already downtown, and our area densifying will also only further push our crime scenes.
is set to build on the mud flats that we already have seismic concerns all of Strathcona is built on mud flats as we know from the flats arterial investigations that we did over the course of what two years Most of the condos downtown are empty. What's to say this won't happen here too? We need serious housing options. With that said, we already did the work. The city voted for it. What's the holdup? Gentrification? I'm requesting council to reject these projects and consider supporting further RACAM renew. Now, considering I have a couple more minutes, I'd also like to express the deep need that we need more park space. Within Strathcona, we need a dog park. This is ridiculous. We've got a dog park with very little fencing. We need water parks. Trillium is built on one of Vancouver's hottest hot spots, and we never got a water park in that space. And our kids need this stuff. In Strathcona, we are at loss. children are suffering from this and by bringing in more more density more as it brings in more issues we don't have parking for it and therefore we also don't have the space for this influx thank you very much council
Good evening, Mayor and Council. My name is Jess Boone, and I'm speaking today as a resident of East Vancouver community. I'm a recent graduate of UBC School of Social Work. I live in Cedar Cottage, but I have deep ties to the downtown Eastside community as a nonprofit worker and someone who supports and stands along side community members who are directly impacted by this proposal. I'm here today in opposition of this application and its current iteration, highlighting concerns around amenities, rapid growth that will overwhelm the surrounding community center, transit and parking road space, I have serious concerns that the needs have identified by residents in the surrounding areas such as planning initiatives through the Ray Can Renewal Plan are not being meaningfully considered alongside this rezoning application. That plan was created in partnership with residents in this exact neighborhood. Community members have clearly identified priorities. We're happy to hear about social housing, but there is a deep need for accessible child care spaces and improved recreation amenities that support the people who already live there. Yet we continue to see rezoning applications that focus on market density and height without clearly addressing these identified needs by residents. It feels as though the city is moving forward with decisions that do not reflect what residents have already said they require to remain safe and housed in their own neighborhood. I want to raise the concern mentioned at the beginning of the public hearing, strain on local amenities. This community has consistently asked for truly affordable housing, family supports, and infrastructure that strengthens existing residents. Instead, proposals like this raise very real concerns about gentrification and displacement. When development moves ahead without embedding the priorities identified through community-led planning, it signals that residents' voices are secondary to private development interests. I urge council to reflect on how these decisions are being received by community members and residents. People are paying attention. Communities remember when they feel unheard. And as we move towards the 2026 municipal election, residents will be considering whether their elected officials truly listened and act in alignment with their community identified needs. And that's all I really have to say tonight. Thank you so much.
yes sorry about that um speaker number nine summit um beau wanamaker yeah thank you very much perfect pronunciation once again uh yeah i'd like to thank yourself and the council for allowing me to speak tonight i would also like to speak in support of agenda item 3 at 10 30 east hastings street and all other applicable parcels This particular housing proposal offers the city of Vancouver to assist a historically underserved area of the community while simultaneously assisting segments of the population who have largely been disregarded from past housing projects. At a time when housing unaffordability and increasing marginalization continue to put pressure on the city, these projects are not just beneficial, but necessary. This housing proposal is incredibly well positioned. Being only a short walk from the new St. Paul's Hospital, which will soon be one of the largest employers of the community, this provides dual assistance to Vancouver. Not only does it provide housing near a major health care hub, but it also supports health care workers, who are a major pillar of Vancouver as a whole. The exceptional positioning of this proposal goes further. Seniors age 65 and older are the largest frequenters of health care services, providing yet another opportunity for this housing proposal to shine. Furthermore, its location on the East Hastings corridor provides yet another reason to support this application. With frequent transit via the R4 passing through the neighborhood, a bus ride to downtown is less than 15 minutes, pushing traffic to be significantly reduced, aligning with the city's desires for a less car-dependent community. The letters of opposition fail to acknowledge the sense of community that is gained by thoughtful increases in density. When density is paired with purpose-built housing for seniors and proximity to services, it fosters connections, walkability, and importantly, neighborhood vitality. An increase in residents means more support for historically underrepresented businesses, safer streets, and even stronger social networks. Furthermore, the density of the proposal does not threaten the character of the neighborhood. Rather, it reflects an evolution of a growing area of Vancouver. The implementation of a building of this size reflects a natural change woven into the fabric of a quickly changing community. Effective planning should never be about mitigating change, but embracing it. The East Hastings project brings sustainable change to the table, and it does so in a way that is thoughtful, responsive, and aligns with the long-term goals of the city. Vancouver cannot effectively respond to the housing crisis if not all age demographics are addressed. this project reflects yet another piece of a growing mosaic of adaptation this proposal supports seniors who deserve to be represented it supports healthcare workers in an increasingly volatile market and most importantly this proposal supports a long-term healthy community cities change Corridors of neighborhoods intensify, but communities evolve when they grow more inclusive. Supporting this particular project means choosing a valuable inclusion over exclusion, progression over regression, and sustainability over stagnation. I ask that Mayor and Council choose the most sustainable path and vote to approve the rezoning at 1030 East Hastings and all other applicable parcels. Thank you very much.
Great. Thank you very much. Speaker number 10, Katie Lewis.
Thank you. Can you hear me? We can hear you, Katie. Please go ahead.
Sorry. I know everyone asked that. Yeah, good evening. Thank you so much. And thanks for the opportunity to speak. I'm Katie Lewis. I'm here tonight to state clearly that I oppose this proposal in its current form. Lived in Strathcona for around 10 years, raising two 10-year-olds, one with a disability on a single income. This neighborhood has taught me so much about resilience, community, care. I was the past VP of the Strathcona Residence Association and sat on the board of the community center as well. So I guess most bluntly, I don't think Strathcona is opposed to new housing or new neighbors at all. What many of my neighbors cannot accept, and myself, is a proposal that effectively discards the downtown Eastside plan in a single move. In my view, it rewrites the downtown east side through the CD1, something no neighborhood plan, in my opinion, should ever be subjected to. This is a mid-rife corridor on industrial land, no rapid transit, no protected cycling, some of the worst, lowest green space in the city, some of the worst air pollution documented in Vancouver. IN THE HIGHEST VULNERABILITY INDEX. I DON'T THINK ANY OTHER NEIGHBORHOOD WOULD BE ASKED TO ABSORB TOWERS AND DENSITIES LIKE THIS. YEAH, THESE APPLICATIONS INTRODUCE THESE 38 AND 39 STORY TOWERS WHERE THE TALLEST RECENT APPROVALS ARE 11 TO 14, I BELIEVE. THAT'S ABOUT THREE TIMES TALLER. And that's not like an evolution. That's like a profound departure from the downtown Eastside plan. Some of the FSRs in terms of density, I believe, you know, I read numbers like 23, 16.
Those are tower district densities.
You know, and another concern I have is the three-in-one. CD1.
I think consolidating three separate sites into a single CD1 turns three independent decisions into one and prevents council from evaluating each building on its own merits.
The downtown east side, including the 2025 update, does not actually support towers here. The update focused on livability, green space, public realm improvements, not new tower heights or densities.
Fourth, I guess, like, livability deficits in the neighbourhood, you know, make this really unworkable. And, you know, I know most people have already touched on it. You know, we have the worst tree canopy. We have overstretched schools and amenities.
We have port... Port trucks, rail activity, industrial, commuter traffic. I think adding 1,000 units without matching public realm investment just doesn't solve deficits. It just deepens them.
Yeah, this industrial land. Two of the three sites sit on M1, industrial land, a category that the city's own industrial land strategy identifies as scarce and essential. It's not replaceable. And once it's gone, it's gone. Four-fifths of these units are market housing, full support of the seniors' housing.
But concentrating all the non-market units into one single mid-rise beside two towers, I don't think reflects integration or balanced growth. I know a couple years ago we had a petition where... 1,257 people signed a petition opposing this proposal, which is an extraordinary number for a neighborhood of our size.
Yeah, I know people have touched on parking, but I actually read that parking report buried deep in the transportation appendix. Okay, so what I read was across 924 units, There was zero resident parking, so not reduced, not low, zero, like on a freight corridor with no rapid transit, no protected bike lanes, heavy truck volume, and narrow sidewalks.
Katie, I'm sorry you're at time.
Okay, no problem. I urge you to amend this proposal as is. Thank you.
Great. Thanks, Katie. Speaker number 11, Will Ebaldi.
hi everybody mayor and council thank you for your time my name is will abale i leave space at 11 29 east hastings where artists work and an exhibition space has mounted 10 to 20 exhibitions and events every year since 2017. i am speaking in opposition to the proposed three tower redevelopment on this block Speaker number nine believes that this proposal is, as he says, quote, responsive, but is it responsible? This application raises a straightforward land use question. Is this the appropriate location for towers of this scale? The site sits directly beside active rail lines and designated truck routes serving the port of Vancouver, which is Canada's largest port. and a critical national trade gateway. These corridors are not secondary streets. They're a strategic goods movement infrastructure operating continuously and essential to the regional and national economy. Placing nearly 100 stories of residential density immediately adjacent to active rail and port-serving truck routes creates a foreseeable and permanent land-use conflict. Residents who move into towers of the scalable reason
noise fewer heavy traffic trucks cleaner air over time though that expectation generates pressure to restrict industrial operations that define this corridor we should not introduce sensitive residential uses in a way that incrementally constrains essential trade infrastructure protecting port adjacent industrial function should remain a long-term priority for the city there's also practical infrastructure reality east tasting street and clark drive already experienced significant congestion particularly with heavy truck traffic moving to and from the port adjacent streets function as industrial connectors are routinely backed up adding this scale of residential density density into an already constrained corridor will intensify that pressure There's no sky train station at this location, and anybody who says that buses are sufficient needs to take the East Hastings bus in and out of this neighborhood to really understand why this is a major issue. Transit service and neighborhood amenities are limited relative to what is proposed. Fewer than 200 park... spaces are planned for almost 100 stories of housing. This does not eliminate vehicles, but instead shifts demand into surrounding streets that are already operating at capacity. That city should follow transit and infrastructure readiness, not precede it. We are told this height is justified by affordable housing. Deep affordability is urgently needed. However, the majority of units proposed are market rental in East 1 and East 2. Council should ask whether permanently transforming height and land value in this block is proportionate to the level of non-market housing being delivered. finally this block currently supports active cultural production working artists and exhibition spaces operate here today affordable creative space in vancouver is disappearing and once demolished it does not retain return equivalent rents cultural infrastructure is important to vancouver according to canada council's 2025 report for every one dollar of investment in arts and culture the sector generates about 29 dollars in overall economic activity proposal concentrates extreme height on infill land immediately beside national trade corridors in an already congested industrial connector without rapid transit and at a cost of functioning cultural space that combination warrants serious CAUTION. I URGE COUNCIL TO REJECT OR SUBSTANTIALLY REVISE THIS APPLICATION IN FAVOR OF AN APPROACH TO BETTER ALLIANCE LAND USE, ECONOMIC INFRASTRUCTURE, AND LONG-TERM COMMUNITY STABILITY. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
Councillor Montague, you're in the queue. Yeah, thanks, Mayor. I'm just looking at the time. I see we've got a handful of speakers left. Looks like we're going to have to extend to finish those. So I'd like to put a motion on the floor to extend past 10 o'clock to finish speakers and your public comments and then refer debate, decision and questions to staff to the regular public hearing on March the 10th in person and by electronic means.
Sorry, is it council meeting or public hearing?
Is it council meeting, Tina? Sorry, not the public hearing, the council meeting on March 10th.
That was your question, Councillor Domino? Okay, so that was moved, seconded. council is there any discussion seeing no one in the queue I'll put that to a vote all in favor say yay hey all those opposed say nay great so we will that motion passes and we will hear the rest of the speakers close off the speakers list and close off comments and then we will have debate decision
during the council meeting March 10th. Thank you. Okay. With that, the next speaker we have is speaker number 12, Sam Valen.
Hi, please go ahead.
hey thanks everyone um I appreciate you all extending the meeting to hear our comments um I just want to say I'll keep this short I found about this I found out about this proposal from a friend and it piqued my interest as a Vancouver resident because I commute to this area on a daily basis I support this proposal particularly because of the inclusion of secured top of spot rental housing that prioritizes affordability In a neighborhood like the downtown Eastside, where low-income residents have experienced decades of displacement, discrimination, and marginalization, it matters deeply that new developments include housing that is protected and accessible to people who need it most. Affordability, however, doesn't stop at rent. Approving a new density in a transit-constrained corridor means approving additional transit demand. And as someone who rides these buses daily, I can tell you that the system is already stretched beyond capacity. Buses are delayed in full, and I've seen people using mobility aids unable to board. I've seen seniors left standing, and I've seen parents with strollers wait for multiple buses to pass. If this housing is added, really even if it's much needed affordable housing, without securing transit improvements, we risk placing an additional strain on the very people we are trying to support. Affordable housing must be payable. with accessible, reliable transportation, and density and transit need to be planned as one system. I urge Council to ensure that these services are increased and that reliable transportation and infrastructure upgrades are confirmed alongside this approval so that growth here strengthens rather than strains the community. That's all for my comments tonight. Thank you, everyone.
Thank you very much. The next speaker is speaker number 13, Louis Mercier. Louis Mercier.
Yeah. Yeah, I am a resident of Vancouver, and I support this proposal. Sitcona is close to downtown and is well served by transit. It makes it a logical place to add more housing. People living here will be able to get around easily without needing a car. This project delivers also a large number of new purpose-built rental homes, along with 157 social housing homes for seniors, adding a mix of housing options in one development. AS A RENTER MYSELF, INCREASING RENTAL SUPPLY AT THIS SCALE CAN HELP KEEP RENTS MORE IN LINE WITH AVERAGE RATES ACROSS VANCOUVER BY GIVING PEOPLE MORE CHOICE IN THE MARKET. MORE SUPPLY HELPS REDUCE OVERALL PRESSURE ON PRICES. I BELIEVE THIS IS A RESPONSIBLE WAY TO HAD HOUSING IN A TRANSIT CONNECTED NEIGHBORHOOD AND I ASK COUNCIL TO APPROVE THIS PROPOSAL.
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. SPEAKER NUMBER 14, DANIEL ANEN.
Council, I appreciate your time and I want to speak in favor of this application. As already said this evening, it will deliver almost 1,000 new homes, and 157 of those being social housing units. And I think especially as the city faces a serious housing shortage, these are exactly the kinds of projects that we need. I want to speak especially to seniors, because I think that the East 3 building is especially important for the community. Seniors deserve the opportunity to age in place, and this project helps make that possible. It keeps them in the community, and it brings them closer to services. I think the partnership with BC Housing also can give confidence to the community that this E3 building especially will be delivered responsibly and managed well. um the development is near st paul's hospital i think it'll add jobs uh health care um near health care and it is also aligned with the city's transit orientated housing plan and the neighborhood's already evolving and with other projects like these underway the proposal continues that momentum in a good and balanced way so ultimately i want to urge council to support this motion and i thank you for your time thank you very much speaker number 50 angus thompson
Yes, we can. Please go ahead.
Okay, thank you very much. Hi, so my name is Angus, and I'm a resident of Vancouver, and I'm speaking to you tonight in support of the proposed project. I am a renter in the city, and I do see a big need for accessible rental spaces and more housing developments in Vancouver, and I know that this feeling and need for more rental spaces is also felt by many of my friends and other members of the community. I think that the proposed development will greatly improve access to housing in this area and help alleviate this issue that we're feeling. And then I also believe that implementing this development will help provide groundwork that future community building projects and community initiatives can build off of. So I urge council to support this project. Thank you very much.
Thank you very much. Speaker number 26, Ming Tang. Sorry, 16. Speaker number 16, Ming Tang. Yes, please go ahead. Hi.
Yeah. My name is Ming Tang. I opposed the C1 rezoning proposal for Hastings Street and Glen Drive in its current form. I'm a resident of Strathcona. I work here and I volunteer starting a family here in the neighborhood as well. I'm very supportive of more housing, especially mixed use and social housing. as most Strathcona people are. However, the sheer size of these proposed buildings is concerning. This is going to bring a lot of new residents and lots of Airbnb, hopefully more of the first and less of the second. We don't even have a grocery store here. With this proposal, the new residents and us existing ones have to leave the neighborhood just to get groceries. The livability of existing residents seems to be a bit of an afterthought. For example, traffic calming measures are currently being added to Glen Drive. This massive influx of residents will only make this worse. If traffic is truly such a concern for the city, why is there no R5 bus stop? And that's R5, not R4 for the other people listening. hox and heatley seems like a great candidate for the r5 bus stop and would go a long way to helping alleviate traffic along this corridor another concern for the neighborhood is empty real real retail spaces i want buildings to be mixed use i want a grocery store i would like these proposals to include plans on how they will attract much needed businesses to fill these spaces I don't want to see more unused spaces in this neighborhood, no matter how shiny they may be. Personally, I think towers that are 20 floors are already a bit much, which are highest in the neighborhood is about that height. This plan is adding buildings almost double that. Please consider lessening the burden to our neighborhood or giving us more infrastructure that can sustain the livability quality and affordability for future and existing residents. To add to the lack of confidence in this project, the CBC reported on West Bank just yesterday regarding the lawsuit with their own ex-VP. So I think this proposal needs to be rejected and reconsidered with community input. Thank you for your time.
Thank you very much. If there are any additional speakers in the chamber, please come forward to the podium. Clerk, are there any additional speakers online?
We do have... Two or three online, but we don't have the name, so if we could take a break, we can get this.
Can you hear me all right?
We can hear you great. Please go ahead.
Great. Thank you for your time, Councillor. And there's a question I have is. more for bc housing and with the recent bc 2026 budget and cuts to potentially large infrastructure projects and the implications it would have on their ability to fulfill the social housing component. My fear is that you have the full market value developments proceed while the low income or under market value development is placed on hold as a result of budget cuts. So I just would like some clarity around the commitment to fulfill obligations to finish on that project.
I am still on the line, sorry. I was just more of a question I put forward.
Yeah, as part of this process, speakers don't ask questions of counsel.
Okay, great. Thank you very much. The next speaker is Maya Seto.
Hi. Thanks for giving me the opportunity to speak up for my neighborhood. I oppose this rezoning proposal, but I just want to be clear. I do support adding more affordable rental units and social housing in Strathcona as well as the rest of Vancouver. And unlike some of the other speakers before me who don't live in Strathcona, I live in the neighborhood. I was born and raised here and I really want to raise my kids here too. Actually, I'm in my last year of a nursing degree program and I work at the Old Saint Paul, so I'm actually hoping to work at the new one and I'm looking forward to hopefully being able to do that in the future.
Quickly, I wanted to agree with previous speakers about building height, the only 17% social housing, the 45 parking spots. And also especially public transit, the R5, not the R4, doesn't stop in our neighborhood. And the segment of that line between Main Street and Commercial Drive is the longest unbroken segment on the entire line other than on Burnaby Mountain itself. And also a quick note about the number 14 Hastings bus service ends at 7 p.m. So, yeah, so that's another bus that's just gone in the evening. We don't have a post office. The Chinatown post office closed. The Woodward's London Drugs is closing. So our next closest post office is going to end up on the drive somewhere. And we don't have very much green space, as others have spoken to. But more on a personal note, one particular thing that I wanted to draw attention to is that there have been more fires in this area in the past few years, and our fire hall, number one, can't keep up. There was more talk about this last year. There's now a temporary hall that's been installed. It's next to the proposed single-story value village development on Hastings at Commercial. The initial plan actually for that home was to destroy one of our few areas of green space over on Core Avenue, but fortunately the plan was revised. But to be clear, that fire hole, it's temporary. And because fires have been increasing, I have been directly impacted by this. In 2023, there was an arson that burned down my dad's home, the house I grew up in, and also two houses next to it. I don't understand how we can possibly go about adding two almost 40-story buildings to this neighborhood without even having adequate fire and rescue services for the people who already live here. I would really appreciate it if you could oppose this zoning proposal but still... In the future, find a way for us to be able to welcome people to our neighborhood in a way that's sustainable and in a way that is beneficial to the people who will move in, but also to the people who live here now. Thank you very much.
Thank you very much. Our next speaker is Russell Wong.
Hi. My name is Russell Wong. I'm a resident of Vancouver. I don't work in real estate or development. I'm calling to support these three rezoning applications. In particular, the third site is for a high-rise to be owned by BC Housing with 150 different apartments for seniors and people with special needs. The 767 market rentals and the other two sites provide secure housing without having to own, and they serve to cross-subsidize the social housing. As I understand it, there's zero displacement of existing renters. The first site is a vacant lot. The second site has two one-story industrial commercial buildings, and the third site has a vacant industrial commercial building. I would emphasize the need to plan for more amenities and for more public transit capacity as more people live in the neighborhood. The two do go together because of the way we finance new amenities from new housing. With respect to traffic, I happened to meet someone a while ago who was planning the staffing of the new St. Paul's Hospital. We need a lot of people to work there, and they need somewhere to live. If we force people to live further away, they end up driving through the neighborhood and adding to traffic congestion. Thank you.
Thank you very much. Now we have three speakers online, I believe. Yes. I just have the last four digits of the telephone number. So the first one would be 8450. Thank you. 8-4-5-0, are you on the line?
Hello? Hi. If you can please state your first and last name and whether or not you're a resident of Vancouver for the record, please.
Yes. So my name is Nicholas Yanome. I am a resident of Vancouver, and I support this proposal. I've lived here for about 10 years now, and the one consistent thing that I've always noticed and heard between friends and everyone around me is that Vancouver needs more rental housing. And from my understanding of this project, it adds a significant number of new rental homes at a time when vacancy rates remain pretty low and people are struggling to find an affordable place to live. Even throughout all Vancouver. It's a location that's connected to transit. It's within easy reach of downtown. And it supports an area that already has existing infrastructure rather than having to start from scratch and having to spend even more time and more resources into.
uh... some of the previous speakers have mentioned uh... did with the new saint paul's opening it even the last speaker uh... it is adding more cars and making more trafficking popping more issues on people sort of work again uh... everything really that the city is trying to work against, and we're just trying to move more towards transit, which is already being worked on. It just makes more sense to add affordable rental housing in areas that already exist, rather, and are already supporting this infrastructure. So I just ask the council to approve this rezoning so that rental homes that are affordable can move forward.
Thank you very much.
So the next speaker's last four digits of their telephone number is 2597. Is 2597 there?
Yes, hello, this is Jane Chernovsky. Hi. I'm a local resident of Strathcona. May I speak?
Yes, please go ahead.
Thank you. So as I mentioned, I'm a local resident of Strathcona, and I'm strongly opposed to this proposal because it threatens the heart and soul of one of Vancouver's oldest neighbourhoods. The scale and height of this development are completely out of step with the historic character that defines Strathcona. This is a place shaped by generations of families, stories and community, not by towers. Approving a development of this magnitude would permanently alter the neighbourhood's identity and erase the sense of history that cannot be rebuilt once it's gone. A proposal of this scale... cannot be supported by existing infrastructure. Transit would be stretched. We have very few green spaces. Schools are full. Parks are lacking. Heritage is not an obstacle to overcome. It is something to protect. Once this character is lost, it is lost forever. I urge this proposal to be rejected.
Thank you very much. Next is last four digits 3-6-4-6. 3-6-4-6, if you could please state your first and last name and whether or not you're a resident of Vancouver for the record, please.
This is me, I guess. My name is Peggy Pickton. and i'm been a resident of the kawasa neighborhood for 37 years um can you hear me you can hear you great please go ahead okay um i haven't prepared for this um i just found out about this meeting um this council meeting today actually so I'm just trying to collect my thoughts here.
There was a very large meeting a year ago, last year, I can't remember if it was a year ago, public meeting with the developer, West Bank, and the city planner. And a great turnout from the Strathcona residents was... was there um looking at the models that were presented the visuals and opportunity to speak with the representatives from from west bank and the city planner all i can say is that I've been here for 37 years, and it's like these proposals are going from zero to 1,000 in terms of density and what currently exists in this neighborhood to support this number of people that is being proposed with these three towers.
The one thing I want to note, the social housing project, some people are referring to it as seniors housing, but I understand that's not a given. It could be any kind of social housing, and it certainly would be good to know what is meant by that. quite a bit of naivety around social housing for homelessness, etc. But that's another topic. When you've lived close to the downtown east side, you would understand what I'm referring to.
Forty-five parking spots for three towers. with hundreds of new people in the proposed towers, hundreds of people. That's just not going to cut it. I think it's been mentioned a few times that this is a semi-industrial, light industrial area. People come here to work. They park their cars. and the residential streets.
And it's very hard to get a parking spot when you're a resident here or if you have friends coming or family. So I can't imagine what's going to happen when hundreds of new people come to this one block area on Hastings Street.
It's just not, 45 parking spots is just, it's not reasonable. And it's not reasonable to think that people aren't going to have cars. The transit, there's no SkyTrain. The bus system, if anybody's taken it on Hastings Street to go downtown or the other direction, they'll just know how inadequate the system is already. It's overloaded, and it's not always a reliable line. It's not the kind of... It's not the top of the line job that bus drivers want. So, yeah, it's tough going using the bus. And people certainly aren't going to be biking if they... have disabilities or if they are seniors that that don't have the capacity so i'm not sure what the answers are for that um i'm sorry we're at time thank you for uh okay great thank you thank you okay have a great night um we have one speaker in the chamber
Please Please come up And if we can please get your first and last name and whether you're a resident for the record my name is Karim Windsor I live in Vancouver I'm a commercial realtor.
I've been looking around this neighborhood It's an interesting It's an interesting neighborhood and the site's quite interesting It's kind of I don't want to say in the middle of nowhere, but it's unusual next to the railway tracks with a you know, like Overpass and Stamps Landing next to it. My clients own just... west of the railway tracks next to the first site, Site 1, at 420 Raymer and 1001 East Pender.
We support the project.
Being the last person here, I got to hear both sides of the argument, and I was chatting with the architect out there that was... quite opposed to it, but I'm supportive of it. It's very hard to find sites in Vancouver to build housing on. We've got a housing crisis. I think the neighborhood could use more housing. I think there's a trade-off between view corridors and more housing, but I think we're having that same trade-off everywhere in the city where I live, where everyone lives. So we've got to make a decision. Do we want housing or do we want a pretty view? And I'm kind of leaning towards more housing. And then there's the parking and no parking. I'm kind of leaning towards, again, more housing. I think it's a good location for more housing. I think this location needs housing. I think it'll help stimulate the area. You're going to get more as you go further east along Hastings and Clark. It's going to come. And I think you've got great developers here. You've got West Bank and BC Housing and Prometa. So I think you've got a great partnership here to provide you with, what, 800 or 900 housing units. I think, I mean... I don't think people building rental housing are making any money on it. I think we need to look at it as a community contribution, any kind of rental housing that they're building. I think we should support that.
I have some questions for the proponents, just because 420 Raymer and 1001 East Pender going to be somewhat orphaned once this goes ahead so is there any possibility for West Bank or BC Housing to include it and maybe build over the railway and build build higher another question I'm curious what the city's view is on just west of the railway tracks, what they want to do there. And Stamps Landing, I think this will give an impetus to maybe add more density to Stamps Landing, but it would be interesting to see what the city thinks of how a lot of density to the east of the railway tracks will maybe increase the social housing to the rest of the railway tracks. So to conclude, I support the project, and I think it's a good location for it. Thank you for your time.
Thank you very much. This is the third and final call for speakers. If there are any speakers for this item who wish to speak to Council, please call toll-free at 1-833-353-8610, followed by participant code 1061445. Before the close of the speakers list, the phone number will be posted on X and displayed during the recess. We're now going to take a two-minute recess for any additional speakers to call in or come forward to the podium.
you
Don't see anybody in the chamber. We do have two online. Again, telephone digits 4105. 4105, if you can please state your first and last name and whether or not you're a resident of Vancouver, please.
Hello there. Yes, thank you for this opportunity. My name is Althea Fowberger and I'm a resident of Kuwasa in the neighborhood of Strathcona. I'm calling to share my very strong opposition to this proposal.
Do we have any speakers in the chamber or online? Althea, can you please turn off your computer's volume? We're getting feedback here.
Sorry about that.
It's okay.
Can you hear me okay?
We can hear you great. Please go ahead.
Thank you. Yes, as I mentioned, I'm a resident of Kewasa in Strathcona, and I'm calling to express strong opposition to the proposed project. um as one of more than 1200 residents and other concerned folks who wrote in to express opposition in the petition which i do hope that council has an opportunity to look at as well as one of the folks who did attend the info session at the russian hall last year that was alluded to previously and in which many many folks from the neighborhood came out to express concerns around some of the aspects of the development proposal that have also been spoken about tonight. One that maybe I'd like to add my voice to is the nature of the units that are proposed in the two rental towers are microsuites, very small units with very few containing bedrooms or that are suitable for families. The kind of units that you know, don't lend themselves to a healthy kind of dignified way of living in the neighborhood. There was also a lot of concerns expressed around the fact that there was no bicycle storage in the units. So it wasn't just about the lack of parking spaces, but also the lack of spaces in which to store a bike or another form of transportation. The units themselves were meant to be the bicycle storage, even in these microsuites. And again, just to address some of the points that have been made earlier around the lack of profitability, of building these towers, I would like for Council to really consider who stands to greatly profit from these pipe exemptions that could go through here. I think Council's probably aware of the owners of many properties in the East Hastings stretch, who those people are, who those developers are, and what kind of potential profits they stand to gain from the precedent set, potentially set, by the removal of the 12-story precedent set out in the downtown east side. So those are just a few of the many, many concerns that have been expressed by people in the neighborhood and by others. And like I said, I really would encourage council to please look at some of those written concerns, both in the petition and that have been shared on the City of Vancouver website. Thank you.
Great. Thank you very much. So the next speaker on line, if you can state your first and last name and whether or not you're a resident of Vancouver, please.
Hello, can you hear me?
Okay, great. Thanks. Hi, this is Naomi Adams. And I'm a resident of Vancouver. Thank you so much for extending the meeting tonight so that you could hear from more folks. I'm calling to urge Council to oppose the proposal in its current form. As I mentioned, I live in Strathcona. I actually live immediately adjacent to one of the proposed towers. I believe many of the points that I would make have already been made by others tonight. I'm not opposed to increasing density in Strathcona. I'm not opposed to increasing density in Vancouver. I grew up in this city, and I am somebody who's lived through this housing crisis. I was recently evicted. managed to only find a place that i was able to afford in strathcona but i do note as other callers mentioned previously that other parts of the city i grew up further west in the city there isn't as much density and so it does feel odd to be accepting this proposal which is quite out of alignment, as others have mentioned, with the plan in the area in terms of the number of stories. And also noting, as others have noted, the lack of amenities already in this neighborhood and that the proposal doesn't include any significant, you know, community center, daycare, I also worry about little details around the proposal. There's a tiny little alleyway that we currently use that would be shared with one of the, I think, 39-story building. And I actually can't imagine how it will functionally work to have cars that going in and out, even a small number of cars. And, yes, that other person just mentioned things like bike storage. That was something we found when we were trying to look for a new place. Like, we don't, you know, we're not a car family. We only have one car that we share. But we have a lot of bikes. Because when you don't have cars, you might have more than one bike. So I really worry that these micro-sweeps, these tiny sweeps,
won't actually meet the needs of of what people are looking for in terms of housing so i know it's super late i won't go on but thank you very much for the time thank you very much we have one more speaker correct yeah if you're online if you can please state your first and last name and whether or not you're a resident of vancouver for the record please
hi my name is amelia epp and i'm a resident of vancouver please go ahead thank you i won't also speak for long i know the meeting has been long thank you for taking my call and i think i would also i think or many of the points that have been made i would echo um like the last speaker i live directly next to the site of the proposed tower one and just wanted to echo a few of the thoughts that the last speaker did share in terms of looking at the proposal and again thinking also there's wanting to state that i'm not opposed um to development and densification in the area and also to providing more um housing units but wanted to express my opposition to the proposal in its current state um i think one of the things that is a concern to me is the size of the unit and i wanted to emphasize the need in our city for and also in our neighborhood for units that can be appropriate for the use by families and there's a real lack of that within the current proposal with the small unit um i also wanted to echo the need for within a proposal there being a addressing the need for amenities in our neighborhood as well And so thinking about, again, daycare, community center, the need for grocery store, green market as well. And just also wanted to emphasize the height that is being proposed as it is. would really result in a huge um jump from a very tall tower to the units that are directly next to it creating this cliff in density um and so wanted to suggest that something more reasonable could be something such as a 14 to 18 story building or 19 to 28 story building which would be more in keeping with other buildings that have already been developed in the area So those were just a few of the points I wanted to share as well. Thanks.
Great. Thank you very much. Clerk, are there any more people online? No. Okay. Seeing no further speakers, the speakers list is now closed. Has there been a large volume of public comments received on this item since 5 p.m.? No. Okay, seeing that there are few or no public comments received after 5 p.m., I'm now closing the receipt of public comments. Okay, so this meeting is being recessed until March the 10th. Oh, adjourned.
Correct me if we have to add more words here. So this meeting's being adjourned until March the 10th at 9.30 a.m. here in the council chamber. electronically and will continue with item number three At which time At which time we will get any closing comments from the applicant and the team member questions the staff and then debate and decision I will remind Council that it's incredibly important you do not engage in any discussion or correspondence in regard to the remaining of this application. So with that, thank you, everyone, and have a great night. Oh, sorry. Councillor Montague, seconded by Councillor Dominato. All those in favour say yay. All those opposed say nay. Great. This meeting is adjourned.
Thanks, everyone.
Nope, it's all... We always do. Yeah, that was a weird one. Thank you very much. Yeah, you don't have to do it now. I'm the culprit because I just. They are. Okay, so do I send them over? I don't know where they. Okay. I have no idea. The counselor's office can take them. Okay. We'll all end up in the same spot one day. Yeah. Thank you for tonight.
Thank you.
Thank you.