CD-1 Rezoning 2268-2294 West 3rd Avenue
Motion 1 · Public Hearing, February 24, 2026
Summary
- Application by Marcon Developments to rezone 2268–2294 West 3rd Avenue and 1902–1912 Vine Street from R3-3 to CD-1, permitting a 22-storey mixed-use rental building with 207 units and 20% below-market rental floor area.
- Site is at the western boundary of the Broadway Plan area (Kitsilano North, Area B); proposal is policy-compliant with minor increases for ground-floor retail and urban design outcomes.
- Height (22 storeys, 71 m) and density (7.1 FSR) slightly exceed base Broadway Plan allowances; staff support the increments as justified by below-grade commercial use and improved urban design.
- 18 existing eligible tenants all chose to exercise right of return; net addition of 187 new rental homes to housing stock.
- Speakers in opposition raised concerns about cumulative infrastructure impacts, shadowing, traffic and laneway congestion, and adequacy of tenant protections, particularly for townhouse tenants facing unit-size reductions under national occupancy standards.
- Speakers in support cited housing supply need, Broadway Plan compliance, walkable location, and benefit to local businesses.
- Councillors noted the TRPP policy review (expected back to Council in 2027) would consider issues raised about moving allowances and bedroom equivalency.
Vote
Public comments
Read all 15 statements
Transcript
6 segments
Okay. So, Council will now make its decision on the application. Do we have a mover for it? Thank you, Councillor Domenato. Seconder? Councillor Montague? Thank you very much. Council, is there any discussion?
seeing no one in the queue oh counselor or sorry yeah i'll jump on um yeah i appreciate a lot of the comments uh here today from folks uh both in support and against um appreciated the comment about our job it's not easy it definitely isn't um we take we take this very seriously i can say that everybody in these chambers takes us very seriously and um We do have to weigh a lot of different things. For me, you know, the TRPP and below market rentals is something that I really look for. And, you know, it's difficult because we're seeing that kind of definitely with the below market rentals kind of stripped away elsewhere. So when I see it still included, I think it's really important. to highlight that that exists. It's not perfect. TRPP isn't perfect, but it's the best we have, and Broadway planning is quite strong on this. So just in light of that and in light of sort of that we have to take each project, you know, with its merits and how it fits into the policy plan, You know, this does fit in with the plan and the policy that's on books. So I will be supporting it on those factors. We do need below market rentals. I know it's not what everyone wants to hear. And I know, you know, you value the time that you've had in the townhouse. And I know it can't be hard. or can't be easy, so I don't make this decision lately, but I think I will support much-needed rentals in this area. Thanks.
Thanks, Mayor, and thank you to all of the representatives and residents who spoke both on the phone and in person this evening. I want to reflect on a couple of things because I thought one of our last speakers articulated it very well, even though I think she said she didn't come prepared, but just that there was some consensus that people love Kitsilano. I think even for those of us who don't love Kitsilano, we love Kitsilano. It's a bit of a gem in the city. And one of the things I heard, one of the other speakers who I appreciate didn't speak in support was representing that they've been in the city for many, many years and that Kitsilano has changed significantly even in 30 or 40 years since the 70s. And I think that is the challenge we find ourselves in and was alluded to by my colleague of trying to strike a balance of how do we try to preserve some of the wonderful heritage and history and character of neighborhoods, but at the same time, accommodate the demand for people wanting to live in these neighborhoods, newcomers, families. Families was highlighted by everyone on both sides of the fence on this. It was both in the loss of sort of the multi-town homes to the fact that people are looking to live in Kitsilano but couldn't find places and the possibility of having three-bedroom family dwellings in the proposal. And so... It is a challenging decision, and I think that some things were clarified. Some of the speakers have raised some questions. I think some of those were clarified by the applicant. I do think there's value in the work that our staff are doing around the policy review around the TRPP. And so as these issues surface as part of public hearings, they will be considered. And then lastly, I think... What also stood out to me, like Councillor Orr, was in this current market, the inclusionary zoning of 20% below market in these projects is difficult. And I didn't get a chance to ask the applicant about their state of readiness and their financing, the ability to actually deliver this, because we do know sometimes these rezonings come forward and then they don't have the capacity to move them. But that is, I think, a real positive in considering the issues of affordability and the housing costs in this region. And then lastly, I heard very clearly, and we don't always hear this from applicants, is that the commitment and passion in being good stewards and speaking to the success they've had with other projects and tenants, and they take pride, it was noted, taking pride in the work. And I think That also speaks volume for the project. But recognizing there are different perspectives on this, and some people will leave here potentially not feeling satisfied or unhappy with Council, but on balance from what I've heard and reviewed, I think that we should support this, and I'm prepared to support it. I did want to reflect some of those comments at the end. Thank you, Mayor.
Thank you very much, Councillor. Seeing no one else in the queue, Council, I'm now going to call the vote.
Clerk, if you can please take us to the voting screen.
Okay, and that passes unanimously.
Statement Watch
Hi, everyone. Hi everyone, I apologize earlier for not being able to hear me. I have listened to all of the speakers though and I love hearing how near and dear Kitsilano is to everyone's heart. I'm from the Kitsilano Business Association and I'm speaking in support of this. We constantly hear that people want to find a place in Kitsilano and they cannot find a suitable place. especially from our businesses that want their employees to be able to live and work in the neighborhood. That's one of our businesses' biggest challenge. We have 278 businesses, so there's thousands of people that work on West 4th, as you can imagine, that live outside of the neighborhood. I understand what the speakers are talking about in terms of congestion and traffic. But I do think that is just what's going to happen in Vancouver. We do need the prices of affordable housing to go down. And that's just a supply issue for our businesses. Of course, I think it was speaker number two, the pharmacist that's an owner-operator of a business for many years. Of course, our businesses welcome those people. I understand there will be a courtyard that will go directly into the Whole Foods. courtyard onto West 4th. So, of course, the 278 businesses that I represent welcome those residents that will be moving into this building to shop and dine and eat and use the services that we offer on West 4th Avenue. I think that's it for me, but I am in support of this project. It falls within the the Broadway line, and I think we do need the density in our city. When I tell people what I do for a living, I constantly hear, oh, I wish I could live in Kitsilano. It's just too unaffordable, and I haven't been able to find housing there. So I think with increased density, there will be opportunity for people to move into this cherished neighborhood. Thank you so much.
Statement Watch
Yes. Hi. Good evening, Mayor, Senate and Council. Thanks for giving me time to speak tonight.
Please go ahead. Can you hear me? Yeah, we can hear you great.
Can you hear me? Okay. My name is Susan Davies. I'm a resident of Kitsilano. I'm also a medical professional who's worked in Kitsilano for the last 36 years. I'm speaking in opposition to the proposal on West 3rd and Vine Street. My primary concern is not so much change itself, it's the lack of comprehensive and transparent mitigation plan for the impact of this project because there are so many other proposals for high towers in this small geographic area. And so I believe this development can't be considered just in isolation. There's dozens of additional high-rise towers planned. We're underway within a few blocks in the same area. And when you layer the projects together, we're looking at a really dramatic increase of the population density, potentially thousands of new residents, without a clear public plan outlining how the infrastructure will keep pace. Infrastructure, I mean roads, parking, the sewers, schools, parks, daycares, preschools, health services, and, of course, emergency access. And as someone myself who works presently in health care, I can tell you that services in this area are already very stretched. Because I have limited time tonight, I'm just going to focus on one specific example, and that's the parking and traffic congestion. I read the report, and the project proposes, as you said earlier, the 207 units. The parking is 88 parking spaces. So for this area, that would be about 200 to 400 residents in that one single building. Where are all the other people going to park? The report does state parking plans will be finalized at the development permit stage. But to me, that leaves a lot of uncertainty. And the reality is that many residents will likely still own vehicles. People have to commute to work. Families drive kids to school and activities. And regardless of people are taking transit, they will be getting their daily deliveries by truck or by car. Trades and service providers will still require access as well as visitors and the ride sharing, and this is all added further pressure. So if parking is insufficient on site, I think that what's going to happen is these vehicles will spill into the surrounding street areas that are already very congested. Emergency vehicle access, the pedestrian safety, and the quality of life I feel will be negatively impacted. Already, I live just across the street, so I'm hearing ambulances blaring every half hour down 4th Avenue, and I'm wondering how will people get emergency care in a timely fashion with further increased congestion? And this is only just the one building. Safeway redevelopment is already underway across the street at the very same intersection. So what we need to consider really is the cumulative effect, which could mean close to 1,000 new residents just in that one little corner. So what I would like to see is the detailed publicly accessible plan that shows how the traffic flow is going to be managed. How will the sewers and utilities be upgraded? Or is 4th Avenue going to be permanently... ripped apart for that or how will schools and health services be expanded i don't see details in that and i think growth needs to be responsible coordinated so i feel this proposal is quite premature and incomplete because the broader consequences of what i've just mentioned haven't been addressed And I read a lot of the Broadway plan. I see the acronym to be determined TBD many times. And I feel if you don't, you don't really have a plan if you have TBD repeated often. So in conclusion, this was just an example of congestion parking issues. Just one of the many areas where there's no, in my opinion, the detailed plan to address the impact of its development. So I'm urging council to pause and require a more comprehensive infrastructure and mitigation strategy and make it clearly available as well as easily accessible to the public before proving the further density at this scale in Kitsilano. Thank you so much for your time.
Statement Watch
Yep.
Can you hear me?
We can hear you great. Please go ahead.
Hello. Good evening, Mayor and City Councillors. My name, as you mentioned, is Darren Leeson, and I've been the owner of the Shoppers Drug Market at the corner of West 4th and Vine Street. We're one block away from this proposed redevelopment. Now, I've been a pharmacist for 46 years, 36 of these in Canada, and I've been at this Shoppers location for 20 years. which is a fair amount of time. And over the past two decades, I've seen 4th Avenue change and grow into one of Vancouver's most popular and desired shopping districts for both residents and retailers. And it's a very trendy place to live, as you know. I've also not seen any new development in the last 20 years. You know, this proposal is located within the Broadway plan area. and is fully policy compliant, providing over 200 new rental homes, including those below market, which is, you know, I think that's really important in a very popular neighborhood. It may seem that Forth is already a busy shopping area, but as a longtime local business owner, I can tell you that all retailers along the street will gladly welcome an increased customer base, especially in this uncertain economy. In the 20 years I've been here, I've seen many businesses on 4th open and close because it's such a competitive environment and with increased population, it will definitely help survival. I've also seen many seniors being forced to relocate with increased rents. So with the rent controls and increased inventory, the rents might stabilize and make it more affordable for people. This project is my support. It brings new rental stock to the area along with public benefits such as a family playground, retail shops, and a mid-block green pathway connection to the Whole Foods Plaza. Please consider improving this policy-compliant rental proposal in Kitsilano. Thank you for your time.
Statement Watch
Mayor and Council, thank you for your time tonight. My name is Alex Downey. I live at 1910 Vine Street in Kitsilano. We are directly impacted by this development. I'm here with my wife, Barbara Downey, to voice our opposition to this rezoning. We are also here to ask you to consider enhancements to the tenant protection relocation plan to consider the impact on those of us that are displaced from townhomes. Most of our neighbors are opposed to this building. Having a tower on this site, the referral report confirms this with, I believe, 69% of respondents against it. But you know that already. Who are we? We are long-term Vancouver residents. We raised our family in our Kitsilano townhome for the past 25 years. Our family lives in this townhome now. As recent retirees, we now live on a fixed income, so we have to consider that. And a little bit about our townhouse complex. It's a 20-unit townhome complex that was completely renovated in 1990, comprised of 15 two-bedroom and five three-bedroom units. We're in one of the three-bedroom units. These are all large 1,200 to 1,400 square feet units with unfinished basements. They're row houses with front and rear porches, level entry to the street. Our townhouses are livable, functional, and affordable family-oriented units. What do we stand to lose if this goes through, if you voted through? We'll lose the unfinished basement space we use for storage, laundry area, and recreation space. We'll lose privacy and quiet because we only have neighbors on two sides now, not above and below. The loss of possible home office space, loss of potential sublet income because it's allowed in our current lease. The ability to age in place by using a bedroom to house a live-in caregiver in the future. And, of course, the loss of the community we have helped to build over the past quarter century. In looking at the different tenant protection policies for municipalities nearby, Vancouver and Burnaby comes to mind. Both, of course, allow a rate of return to a unit in the new building. However, there's some important differences. One of them is that... A national housing standard is applied to reduce the number of bedrooms in the returning unit for certain people. The moving allowances are greater in Burnaby by $400. And in Vancouver, we're paid a moving allowance once of $1,000 for a three-bedroom unit, but not to return to the new building, ironically. So that's a hidden expense in addition to the increased damage deposit that was required to be paid to the new landlord. In Burnaby, developers must post a bond to ensure that the project is completed so the rent top-ups can continue for up to 36 months. Vancouver has not made this a requirement. The bottom line is that Burnaby does not apply the national housing standard. You get like for like for number of bedrooms. And just yesterday, Surrey announced a major project in Surrey Central. by Ani, which is one of the major developers, to replace 321 units. And part of the stipulation is that they will replace them with like-for-like bedrooms for displaced tenants. So what do we stand to go from a three-bedroom, 1,400-square-foot townhouse possibly to a 388-square-foot one-bedroom apartment in the new tower? That just doesn't seem fair. So as townhome tenants, what we'd like to see happen is that tenants displaced from rental townhomes be allowed to return to a unit in the new building with the same number of bedrooms as before, that the moving allowance be increased to $1,400 to match what Burnaby pays, and also to cover inflation since Vancouver hasn't raised moving allowance since 2015 when the policy came into effect, and also that a second moving allowance be paid so that tenants that do elect to return to the building have some assistance to move back into the new building. There are some precedents for this. The TRPP was changed to relax the national housing standard for single persons returning to new buildings. They can return to a one-bedroom instead of a studio as before. And in 2021, the city allowed tenants of townhomes in the Ashley Marr Co-op in South Vancouver to return to new units with the same number of bedrooms they had before, with two moving allowances paid. So why should the city agree to our request? Citizens of Vancouver, especially long-term tenured tenants, deserve to be treated fairly. The cost to demolish our townhome complex is lower than for a typical three-story walk-up building with an underground parking lot. Some of these savings could go to helping tenants' compensation. Compensation should consider the type of dwelling renters are being displaced from. Applying a one-size-fits-all is neither fair nor equitable. To conclude, we don't think it's fair that our standard of living should be reduced markedly to improve developers' profitability. I would like to ask council to instruct planning staff to include policies similar to Burnaby and Surrey to require the developer to provide the same number of bedrooms in the replacement units. Thanks for your time. Thank you very much for coming in, Alex.
Statement Watch
And I hope I pronounced your name correctly. You did. Thank you, Mayor. Thank you to the Mayor and to the Council for giving us this opportunity. My name is Adam Bogoch. I've lived in Kitsilano for 12 years. I am an owner and resident of the Capers Building, which sits directly behind the proposed site, which I vehemently oppose. A few weeks ago, When the barge struck the Arthur Lang Bridge, traffic across Richmond and Vancouver collapsed into total gridlock. One disruption exposed how inadequate our road systems are. And I begin here because what I'm about to show you is a smaller version of the same problem, but permanent. This rezoning sits directly beside one of the busiest commercial service alleys in Kitsilano, the alley serving Whole Foods, and the Capers Building Complex, which is the entire block on the north side of 4th Avenue between Vine Street and U Street. The alley is not a quiet residential lane. It is a high-intensity loading corridor operating above capacity every day. Delivery trucks line up three to five deep. They park to abreast, they block one another, and they block residents and cyclists. Verbal and physical altercations have broken out. Even the city sent soil testers for the proposed property just a few weeks ago, recently had to back out of the alley because it was impassable. I see this daily from my office above the Whole Foods dock. Next slide, please. Next slide. If you reference the developer's application, pages 17, 35, 36, 38, 41, 44, 45, and 47, yes, there's a lot of them, you will see a pleasant animated mid-block corridor connecting 3rd Avenue through the alley into what they label a public plaza leading to 4th Avenue. You can go to the next slide, please. And the next slide again. This plaza is not public. It is common property, owned, maintained, secured and paid for by the commercial strata of the Capers building. In summer months, signage states that the Whole Foods is for customers only. The developer does not own it. They do not maintain it or insure it. Yet, they are marketing it as a pedestrian through route to support their project. Worse, their rendering of the lane depicts leisurely dog walking and cycling as though this was a residential street. It is not. It is a commercial loading dock. Next slide, please. And the proposed four-level underground park gate entrance would sit directly across from the Whole Foods loading bay, intensifying conflict in the tightest, most constrained part of that corridor. Next slide, please. That's their walkway. Next slide. No other high-rise development in this area sits atop this level of sustained commercial activity. Next slide, please. So to that add... 200 units, add construction vehicles and service vehicles and ride shares and deliveries and bikes and pedestrians and traffic from the Safeway redevelopment across the street there and the congestion from 4th Avenue where buses already straddle lanes because the roads are so narrow. And the sidewalks are even worse for pedestrians. Next slide, please. With this, you are not solving a housing problem. You are creating a predictable safety and infrastructure failure. Drivers will suffer. Cyclists and pedestrians will suffer. Commercial tenants and existing residents will suffer. And yes, the future residents of this tower will suffer. Next slide, please. Next slide. If sewage and water capacity must be upgraded for densification, then above-ground infrastructure must reflect the same logic. The roads, lanes, sidewalks, and servicing corridors must be capable of handling the population that you are introducing. This alley cannot. Kitsilano can evolve, but evolution must respect context. This proposal, as it stands, totally ignores it. I urge you, do not approve a rezoning application that relies on misrepresented public space, idealized drawings, and infrastructure that already fails under existing demand. This is categorically the wrong project for this location. And I know I'm fighting an uphill battle here, but should this application pass, it needs to be done so with considerable and notable amendments, which should be brought forward for meaningful public debate. Thank you so much. for your time and consideration.
Statement Watch
Hi there. Yeah, I'm on the line. Can you hear me?
We can hear you great. Please go ahead.
Okay, yeah. Hi, my name is Ed Evans. I'm a Vancouver resident, and I'm calling to offer my support for this application. So I used to live in Kislano and Fairview for many years before relocating to East Van because I couldn't find suitable housing in the neighborhood. And so like many others, I couldn't stay in the neighborhood. I still know the area very well and spend lots of time there. It's an incredibly connected neighborhood with access to beaches, parks, schools, shops, transit and community management. Now that I have a family of my own, I appreciate even more how ideal this area is for kids. It's walkable, safe and families can meet their daily needs without having to rely on a car. I also strongly support the inclusion of pedestrian friendly design features in new developments. The proposed mid-block connection linking West 3rd Ave and West 4th Ave is a great example. Overall, I believe this is a great proposal that responds to the needs of the community and the city. Thank you very much.
Statement Watch
Is it on? Yeah, okay. Good evening. So my name is Ruth Cherry. I've lived in Vancouver since 1985, and I'm opposed to the CD1 rezoning, 2268, 2294, Worcester Avenue, and 1902 to 1912 Vine Street. And what concerns me is that we are told that there is a housing shortage. There certainly is. There's a shortage of affordable housing. I don't think that the number of towers that are in this proposal, this proposal, but also the buildings in the surrounding area are truly going to address that because the rent is not affordable. I don't know whom it is. And maybe if you have three people sharing a small place, I don't know. But as it stands, it's not. And the floor space is quite cramped as well. People have talked about the narrow streets. I often go to Kitsilano. I lived there for several years. And it's very congested. So if you have this building and a number of other buildings in the same area, it will be more so. And I think there will be, as the gentleman, one or two speakers back said, there will be more road rage. People are... not very patient. It concerns me that there's such a it seems a rush to have a number of these buildings built or at least approved to be built without consideration of infrastructure. such as schools, parks, health facilities, and it has to be more livable. It feels like we're losing our status as a livable city because we're allowing development to come at a rate that isn't sustainable.
So that's that part.
Kitsilano has quite a unique character. I remember coming to it in the 70s when I was quite small, and it's changed substantially since then. But it still has character that is hard to find in other parts of the city. With... This building and a number of other buildings, the fabric of that neighborhood is being changed, and I don't think it's for the better. So developers and construction companies say that they're, in essence, doing us a favor by building these tall buildings that are overcrowded, are overcrowding the area. I don't think they're truly concerned about... Us, people who live here, they're concerned about making money. That's their mandate. As for the 20% that are under market value, we don't know how many people are going to be returning. Therefore, how many people in the public, outside of those who are being displaced, are truly going to have access to that 20%. So I hope you refuse this, and thank you for listening.
Statement Watch
Good evening, Mayor and Council. Firstly, I'd like to acknowledge that Council's job is not an easy one. You have to weigh complex and often competing priorities. I'd also like to highlight the power that you hold. Power to have direct and significant effect on people's lives. And as we all know, with great power comes great responsibility. As a 10-year resident of the townhouse complex affected by this application, I, my family, and my neighbors will be greatly affected by your decision. For us, this is not just another rezoning application. Unless you're directly affected in this way, it's truly hard to understand what this is like. Growth is inevitable. The form it takes is a choice. There's substantial research showing that the form buildings have affects quality of life. That ground-oriented housing, townhouses, low-rise buildings, homes with direct street access, foster stronger neighborhood interaction and a greater sense of belonging. Human-scale development supports vibrant, safe communities because it encourages everyday social contact. Tall residential towers reduce informal interaction and increase anonymity. Our townhouse complex is not just a collection of units. It's a community. Neighbors know each other. Children play. People look out for each other. Replacing our community with a tall tower is a dramatic shift. It not only changes the skyline and shadowing, but also the rhythm and character of our neighborhood. We all know that the rental market has shifted towards more availability and softer rents. Current developments and kits will eventually add over 10,000 rental units to our neighborhood. some low rises, 11 towers at the south end of Burrard Bridge, and five other towers you have approved so far. We already had a misstep in the 60s and 70s when the city rezoned to allow 10- to 12-storey towers. A half dozen were built until community action successfully stopped them from spreading further, preserving the character of our neighbourhood. This will undoubtedly happen again. I'm not saying don't build. I'm saying build within the neighborhood's style and character. Besides the aforementioned half-dozen 12-storey towers, most building in kits are three storeys. So build more of these or slightly higher on sites that are less dense. Build livable units that meet the BC housing guidelines, not overpriced shoeboxes. Provide fair replacement for displaced residents. Suites of similar size. Developers may be required to offer suites at a similar rent, but they are half the size. My family would go from 1,200 square feet to 600 square feet. So really, residents' rents are doubling per square foot. I speak to you in the spirit of the city's mission statement, which reads, create a great city of communities that cares about our people, our environment, and our opportunities to live, work, and prosper. Kitsilano is like a golden egg, fragile, precious, and irreplaceable. Careful hands are needed to nurture it, because once it's broken, its value and beauty can simply not be restored. Its value is not monetary. I respectfully ask you to consider whether this proposal strengthens the fabric of our neighborhood or fundamentally alters it in ways that cannot be undone. I ask you to look into your hearts and souls and ask yourselves, in 20 years, will you be proud of what you've done to Kitsilano? Were you responsible with the power you held? I know this is not an easy decision for you. You have pressures coming at you from all sides. But I ask you to respect our neighborhood and those who live there and choose community over profit. Thank you for your time.
Statement Watch
Hello? Can you hear me?
We can hear you great. Please go ahead.
Okay, thank you. I'm here today to urge you to vote no and delay this approval until the developer and city can demonstrate stronger tenant protections are put in place than current. As heard previously at the last council meeting that approved rezoning for the Broadway plan, tenants from the BGH and Canby area spoke out and told city councillors their personal stories about not being rehoused and offered compensation. Instead, they were forced to move out of the city completely. Tenants want assurances that they will be rehoused and allowed to return into equivalent size family units for their family's needs and for the amount of people that are actually living in the units. I know firsthand how weak protections are in my parents' building, which is this building. Residents of the building are currently paying below market rates. Residents are terrified to come and speak. There's been a few of them at City Hall, but most of them are too scared to come and speak at City Hall because they're concerned that there will be repercussions if they do. Families asked the developer at one of the Zoom consultation meetings that was held that they would be rehoused in units of the same number of bedrooms, and they were told that they would be reassessed later on to determine units size. and that there was a limit of how many units would be available below market rate. For many, this means pressure on families to split up or even for their children to move out early, with many not being able to afford further education without being able to live at home with their parents. In the current building, many of the units are multi-generational family units with grandparents, parents, and young children living in the suites together. Many families rely on the shared housing for child care, elder care, and affordability, and now they're fearing that they will be crammed into studio apartments or one-bedrooms. Is this displacement disguised as development? This Broadway redevelopment plan represents a massive transfer of land from residents in the neighbourhoods to private corporations and investment firms. If we allow this to proceed, corporations will continue to control the majority of the rental housing, dissipating market rates and occupancy as they see fit. Rental housing will become like diamonds, scarce and withheld and rationed, while families struggle to afford a place to live. I ask you to delay this proposal until the developer and city staff can demonstrate that residents will be protected adequately, that families will be assisted with stronger policies to protect them than what is currently in place, and that the tenants of the building have already spoken out in other areas saying that they were not rehoused. The Broadway plan does not demonstrate an adequate way and how the city is expanding infrastructure, such as schools, hospitals, sewers, hydro lines that meet the density that is being proposed with the amount of high rises. Unless, of course, the units are meant to be lived in by single people without families or left as untenanted investments. I ask that you make an amendment to the approval process that the developer must show evidence that they have a comprehensive plan for rehoming the residents and units. The units must be at the same size and the same bedrooms to what is currently tenanted as the majority of the residents are living multi-generationally in two to three bedroom family units. Please guarantee that the families can continue living together, as currently there is no guarantee that they will be offered units that will be comparable to what they are currently living in. Please vote no to assume change. Stand with the residents and not developers. Thank you.
Statement Watch
Please go ahead. Hello?
Can you hear me? Hello?
Can you hear me?
Sorry. Yes, we can hear you. Yes, we can hear you. Please go ahead. And can we please restart the timer?
Okay, sorry, I just was unable to get connected before, so thanks for hearing me. Good evening, Mayor and Council. My name is Andrew Seymour, longtime resident of Vancouver. I was born in White Rock, chose to live in Vancouver following my schooling at UBC, and I'm choosing to raise my two boys here. I'll keep my comments brief as possible this evening. We need more family-oriented, attainable rental housing in Vancouver. I know this personally. My family and I had a really difficult time finding a three-bedroom rental in Kitsilano. It really shouldn't be that hard. We spent literally months looking for a home that could meet our needs. We've got two young boys, and the reality is that there's simply not enough newer family-sized rental homes in the neighborhood. We managed to get in the building by our friends leaving a certain condo and got in there in Kitsilando, and without that connection and sort of our friends leaving and sort of finding an angle in, we wouldn't have been able to find accommodation and kits. So that's why I'm really encouraged to see there's three better units in this proposal, along with meaningful commitments to... below-market rental homes, having 20% of the units below market rate, including those three beds, will make a difference for folks being able to live in kits. It's a great spot, really great sense of community, vibrant local businesses, schools, parks. Everything's really walkable, and that's what this offers. um that's traditionally been there and this project supports that so uh mayor council i hope you uh vote all in support of this project this evening thank you great thank you very much councillor montague um okay okay thank you um clerk who's the next speaker online yes we the next person online is adrian tom adrian can you hear us Yes, I can. Can you hear me?
Statement Watch
All right. Good evening, Mayor and Council. My name is Adrienne Tom. I was born and raised on the west side of Vancouver, and I'm calling to offer my support for this application. I used to rent a condo not far from the site, and this was my go-to shopping area, so I know the neighborhood very well. I've seen our city evolve my entire life, and change is part of what keeps Vancouver vibrant and alive. Neighborhoods grow, demographics shift, community needs evolve, and thoughtful change is how we ensure the city continues to thrive for the next generation. I also understand that change can feel uncomfortable, but in this case, it's needed, and I think really positive. This application will deliver more than 200 secured rental homes, including below-market rental at a time when housing availability and affordability are critical challenges. These are long-term homes that will support a mix of residents, including families, which is ultimately the reason I moved further east. If this project was built and ready for occupancy a few years ago, I would have chosen this building over the older condo I rented. I truly hope you support this proposal. Thank you for your time.
Statement Watch
Thank you very much, Mayor and Council.
I want to say some words in opposition to this project. Not total opposition, but I just think that based upon what I've heard tonight and what I've seen in the plan, the overall Broadway plan, there are some things that I think still need to be considered. And by the way, I'm not a resident of Kitsilano, but I'm a very frequent visitor to Kitsilano, Kitsilano Yacht Club, Royal Vancouver Yacht Club. I've spent a lot of time in Kitsilano and I've seen a change significantly over the last 15 years. Some of the speakers have made some very good points tonight. Change is inevitable. The council and the mayor have significant responsibilities when it comes to leading. um there's been comments about the the livability of the area as it has changed over time and i think that one of the most important things that was said tonight was by speaker susan davies when she pointed out that there are a lot of tbds in the plan um i think that is a is a almost a fatal flaw in the plan for instance I would think the plan would want to, when it says we're going to have more parks, be specific about this. Because the livability of Kitswana is going to change dramatically with an influx of people. For instance, we say there's 207 units in this building, but there's not. Because the people that are in the buildings being displaced are going to take some of those 207. So it's less than 207 in total. If we're going to put green space in, I couldn't see any spot about green space in the plan. So a way to say that would be all of the condos and apartments on 3rd Avenue between Arbutus and Vine, all of those people are going to be relocated into this building. Those apartment complexes would be demolished and all that would be turned into this beautiful park. And when you consider the fact that there are other buildings going on how are those buildings going to affect the neighborhood and the need for parks in in the kitsilano fourth avenue third avenue fifth avenue area so there needs to be some more thought it seems on how all of these buildings are going to integrate together to make this a neighborhood that is livable in the future And maybe there's a little bit of self-interest here because one of the places I like to go to is Jackson's on 4th, and it's really hard to get a reservation these days. There are more people coming in. How difficult will it be to shop in all the stores along 4th Avenue with 2,000 new residents over the next several years? So I think my advice is just maybe pause, rethink about how all these buildings can get integrated together. and how all of the things that are identified with TBDs need to be actually addressed before a shovel hits the ground. So I just hope that the council would consider that in their deliberations. Thanks for your time. Appreciate it.
Statement Watch
My name is Louis Villegas. I am a Vancouver resident practicing urbanism in Canada and the U.S. for 40 years. Next slide, please. I oppose this proposal as I oppose towers building in the neighborhoods outside the downtown generally. The Broadway plan is the worst plan I've encountered so far in my professional career. Next. And I project this image on... In council chambers, I am left with two impressions. One, on the one hand, there's a consensus of this chart published by Global News accurately diagrams the housing crisis. But on the other hand, the voting record reveals that the party in power is hell-bent on perpetuating the housing crisis.
Next.
Read the same message in the zoning bubble diagrams in the staff report. The financialization of land is being passed off for urban design. Next. Here is proof. The towers in the foreground were all approved here. The urbanism, the architecture, the planning, everything is low class. City making of Vancouver is in a tailspin with towers and slot machines out of control.
Next.
This proposed tower will destroy property values by shadowing the houses across the lane. Is there a legal case to be made by property owners and residents? prosecuting a class action suit against government for loss of property value and reduction in the quality of life. Next. Let your eyes follow the shadows. Residents and walk-up apartments lose. Houses and townhouses lose as well.
Next.
The quality of the public realm is also diminished by tower shadows. Next. Here, the model accurately predicts the right approach to towers. The downtown peninsula is seen in the distance as a tower zone, jutting out into Burrard Inlet. Seen from far, far away, the towers appear smaller and don't block the views.
Next.
The lesson is crystal. Keep the towers out of the neighborhoods.
Next.
Every tower casts a shadow. We already have canyon streets downtown where the sun doesn't shine anymore. Now Vine Street on the left is lining up for the same result.
Next.
Lower left, human-scale structures surrounded and overwhelmed by towers. Behind the foreground towers, human-scale urbanism is surrounded by towers. The wheels are circling, but the profits are still flowing.
Next.
Fourth Avenue Village features towers blocking views, towers shadowing yards, parlors, kitchens, bedrooms, and the public realm. Towers blocking the view of the Sky Dome. This is the worst possible urbanism.
Next.
Profits are soaring, sort of. The push is up, not out. Government chooses land inflation, not ecological hub-and-spuck urbanism. hub-and-spoke urbanism where GAAP guarantees affordability to all Canadians. How could it be otherwise when Canada is the largest democracy by land mass? We are not running out of land. Government has run out of imagination and more than a modicum of common sense. Next. We've seen it all before. Both Charles Baudelaire and the Impressionists were in full force during the modernization of Paris. The Impressionists immortalized the towns on the periphery of Paris. Baudelaire immortalized the products of modernizing the city, dubbing them the flowers of evil. Next. Tonight, the party in power and those voting in step betray no interest in ending the housing crisis.
Next.
Building the concrete jungle, they do it one tower a town, one vote at a time, one slot machine at a time. In October, next please. In October, the voters face a binary choice. Thank you for the opportunity to speak.
Statement Watch
Thank you. Good evening, Mayor and Council. My name is Bailey Maezga, and I'm a lifelong Vancouverite. For many years, I lived blocks from this site. My childhood home and my apartment were just blocks away. So I know the area very well, and I'm in support of this proposal. While recognizing that change can feel scary, I think this is a great project that will enhance kits and allow more people to join the community. Kids is a wonderful area and we should continue to ensure it remains welcoming and inclusive by encouraging the development of market and below market rentals. So I hope you vote in favor tonight. Thank you.
Statement Watch
Hi, I'm Marissa. I didn't prepare. Can you hear me? Everybody hear me well? I didn't prepare for this, so excuse me. I'm opposed to this. I live and work in Kitsilano. And one thing that's really kind of, you know, we're all coming together on one thing here, and that's that we love Kitsilano. We love the character. We love the heritage. We love the community. We love the walkability. We love the parks and the beach and all of this amazing stuff that is Kits. And I understand the people that are calling in for it who are saying, you know, we want the chance to move back to the community. And I think there's a tasteful way to do that. You know, mid-rise buildings. But why does it have to be 20 stories? Because what these 20-story buildings are really going to do is all those reasons people want to stay and come back, they're not going to be there anymore. They're not going to be keeping people in the area. And it's unfortunate and it's sad. And I've lived here my whole life. And it's been my favorite neighborhood. And it's just devastating to imagine what it's going to look like in the next few years. I oppose this, and thank you for listening.